Movie genres tend to follow certain rules. In this “documentary” by John Wilon, the filmmaker attends a Hallmark movie writing workshop, wherein the tried-and-true formula for a Hallmark holiday movie is espoused. The people are good looking, the religious aspects of the holidays are sidestepped, and financial problems are solved via deus ex machina. (I’ve never seen a Hallway holiday film, though I was tempted by Hot Frosty). Documentaries also have certain rules to them, and those rules are presently being subverted and manipulated by two very good “documentary” filmmakers. One is Nathan Fielder whose You Can See Everything has become a box office hit (and will be the subject of a forthcoming review). The other is John Wilson, who made The History of Concrete.
To understand what it is you are watching here, it is useful to watch a couple of episodes of his HBO TV Series How To. That series ran for 3 Seasons of 6 episodes each. Each episode was no longer than 20-30 minutes. But that short length masks the work that it must have taken to obtain the material for each episode, which is full of clips, most only seconds long, of bizarre happenings on the streets of New York City. John Wilson appears to be walking around New York City all day every day, filming everything and taking meticulous notes, and then, having obtained a stupid amount of material over the course of a year, reverse engineering the same into 20-30 minute episodes (a total of 3 hours for each year/season) that are ostensibly about something like “Scaffolding” or “Splitting the Check” or “Being Spontaneous”. Sometimes, just walking around the street, he stumbles into larger than life events, like the giant lines at Food Bazaar that formed when everyone was in crisis mode, stockpiling groceries at the start of the COVID-19 Pandemic. This he included in an episode about how to make risotto. It is a special treat to watch these documentaries as someone who lives in Ridgewood, Queens, since that too is where John Wilson lives. I recognize plenty of these places. I used to live a few blocks away from that Food Bazaar supermarket. I watched this documentary at Low Cinema, John Wilson's movie theater in my neighborhood.
When you watch a John Wilson documentary, you find confirmed the old adage that fiction is like painting and nonfiction is like sculpture. The former is additive. You start with a blank canvas and add material. The latter is deductive. You start with way too much material and chip away at it until it eventually resembles something. Because the amount of material John Wilson has is so vast, his documentaries feels kind of impossible next to more formulaic talking heads documentaries. There is only one other documentary that kind of feels like this, which had a similar kind of making-of backstory. That would be Exit Through the Gift Shop, which was about a guy who compulsively filmed everything, and then met a bunch of street artists and started filming them. (One of the street artists, Banksy, took the material and made a documentary about the filmmaker.)
To help John Wilson try to fit all of these multitudinous pieces of material together, he decided to make his movie about concrete, a substance which is everywhere. And then there is (perhaps) a large inside joke in the movie where John Wilson tries to get someone, anyone in the movie industry interested in a movie about concrete. I say “perhaps” because based on how good How To was, and how cheap it probably is to have John Wilson just walk around and film things, I would expect his producers wouldn’t have cared what John Wilson wanted to make a documentary about. There is a lot of hand-wringing by John Wilson, in narrative voiceover, as to whether people will want to see his film, but I’m not sure how much of that is real. After all, because of his style, the movie was never going to be just about concrete.
John Wilson’s secret weapon here is his blank persona. He is very much not like other documentarians who seek to get material out of ordinary people. Many others (a good example being Sacha Baron Cohen) would simply not have the patience to let people be interesting on their own terms. But John Wilson, soft-spoken and working alone, has this ability to let things develop. I would expect most of the time, things don’t develop, but if you do it enough, you will every once in a while capture stranger than fiction happenings and meet stranger than fiction people. Take the following course of events. John Wilson travels to a small town in Ohio to visit the World’s Oldest Concrete Street. He talks to a few people about it. He finds out that this town also has the shortest street in America (pretty short) and the tallest spot in Ohio (not that tall). You get the sense that this town has all these records because they are the only town trying for them. One of the people John Wilson talks to about the concrete street is the driver’s education instructors that use the street for their student drivers. John Wilson takes a ride-a-long with one of the instructors. The street could be maintained a little better. Then he visits their office and has another discussion. Then one of the female workers invites him to her house to talk about something else. At her house, John Wilson notices something on the wall. It is, the woman explains, a memento from her deceased husband. It is a framed tattoo. There is a company that takes tattoos off dead people (the skin with the tattoo), cures it, preserves, and frames it for you to display in your house. John Wilson visits this company and talks with the people who run it. They are ordinary people who act like they are doing normal things and find the whole idea of being interviewed for a documentary a curiosity. John Wilson is polite throughout letting the scenario speak for itself. We get to see a large back tattoo professionally preserved.
That is an example of how occurrences that are set up by the subject matter (remember it started with John Wilson deliberately visiting the world’s oldest concrete street) and persistently followed result in bizarre material. The other trick is when bizarre material happens randomly, but then needs to be reverse engineered so that it fits into the movie. The main character in this movie is a part-time musician that is introduced nearly half way through it. He plays in small bands that don’t really draw crowds. He also has side-gigs handing out samples of alcohol in liquor stores where I expect John Wilson met him for the first time (that store is in my neighborhood). This guy, at least 50-years-old and out of shape, would appear to be a somewhat deluded kind of loser. He talks about doing what you love and living your best life, but doesn’t appear to be at all successful. But then some utterly bizarre information is dropped about him. He is in a long-term relationship with a very successful high profile woman. For reasons I won’t spoil, John Wilson is unable to interview her, but he does attend a function in her honor, a place where the musician would be completely out of place. Apparently, this woman is living a double-life, working in a high prestige field and then in her free time conducting a secret romance with this inspired bohemian. It gives the part-time musician and his outlook on life a strange validation.
But how to tie that into a movie about concrete? Well, if you have a subplot about how to make a successful documentary then John Wilson, in a narrative voice-over, can bring up what kinds of documentaries are successful: documentaries about musicians. And at that point you can give an example, but instead of just any successful documentary about musicians (say 12 Feet from Stardom), you instead bring up the documentary about DMX’s Christmas Album. And then when one of the people in your documentary, about an hour further into the movie, randomly name-drops DMX, you have what is a seemingly highly coincidental call-back. But is it a coincidence? Because (if I am right about this), the only reason why DMX was brought up in the first place was because someone in real life name-dropped him at the end of the film. Keep in mind that John Wilson’s narrative is created after the fact. He’s already captured all of the documentary footage, (he has that DMX name drop in the bag) and then he records his voiceover during the editing process.
This is one of those movies where you wish you had an audio commentary in which John Wilson explained exactly how he made the movie, because you will never be able to figure it out just by watching it. It isn’t a straight documentary, but then again, it is so good that you forgive the manipulation. And with that note, my next review will be about Nathan Fielder.



.jpeg)

.jpg)


