Search This Blog

Showing posts with label gwyneth paltrow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gwyneth paltrow. Show all posts

Monday, April 6, 2026

Marty Supreme (3/5 Stars)





When the Coen Brothers split up in 2019 and made separate movies, it was illuminating what projects each of them chose. Joel Coen, the elder brother, made a black and white adaptation of William Shakespeare’s Macbeth starring Denzel Washington and Frances McDormand. Ethan Coen, the younger brother, made two screwball dark comedies featuring lesbians and starring Margaret Qualley, Drive Away Dolls and Honey Don’t. One could discern if one chose what part of their shared canon came from the more serious dramatic brother and what part came from the more quirky comedic brother. Not surprisingly, you need them both to have that signature Coen Brothers dramatic quirkiness. Hopefully their split is temporary.

The split up of the Safdie Brothers, writer/directors of Good Time and Uncut Gems, is equally as revealing. In the fall of last year, Benny Safdie, the younger, made his directorial debut with The Smashing Machine starring Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson. A few months later, Josh Safdie, the elder, made his directorial debut with Marty Supreme starring Timothee Chalamet. Both are ostensibly sports movies in that they are about athletes. Beyond that they couldn’t be more different and reveal that in the brother’s previous partnership, it was most likely Josh Safdie who was the dominant creative force. Mary Supreme is far more like Good Time and Uncut Gems in writing, direction, and style than The Smashing Machine is. The most interesting thing though is that The Smashing Machine is a better movie and contains what Good Time and Uncut Gems had but Marty Supreme does not: an emotional core and a general point. Or to put it another way, what Good Time, Uncut Gems, and The Smashing Machine have in common is that they ultimately have something to say. Good Time, Uncut Gems, and Marty Supreme are alike in that the stories have the same subject matter and style, they all energetically swirl around morally dubious hustlers in New York City.

What is Marty Supreme about? It stars Timothee Chalamet as Marty Mauser, as an aspiring athlete in 1950s New York City (I think I recognize these streets from where Marlon Brando was shot in the first Godfather movie). Since Marty Mauser looks like Timothee Chalamet, his choices of sports are limited. Here, he plays table tennis, an otherwise obscure sport that is just being organized into international competitions.

Marty needs money for the airfare to get to certain competitions. Unfortunately, for reasons unexplained, his mother wants him to be a shoe salesman (or something) and keeps stealing his money. Also, when he does get to the first competition in London, he does not win and thus does not win the prize money and fame he was counting on. That competition involves a surprise entry by a Japanese player who is his opposite in personality. He is stoic where Marty is epicurean, calm where Marty is frenetic, humble where Marty is egotistical. The movie is at its most interesting when they spar off for the first time. This occurs in the movie’s first hour and Marty loses. True to form, Marty is a sore loser and accuses the other player of cheating.

We think there will soon be some sort of rematch. But this does not happen for a long time. Instead, Marty’s mom steals his airfare money again and Marty spends the next hour and a half on various side hustles trying to get to the next tournament in Tokyo. These schemes all work until they don’t and by the two-hour mark he is no closer than he was at the hour mark. Marty is also a giant asshole (not unlike Robert Pattinson in Good Time and Adam Sandler in Uncut Gems) that pisses off everyone he meets, thereby burning every bridge and effectively ending his dreams by the time his rematch with the Japanese player starts. He wins that rematch, but by then it doesn’t matter whether he wins or loses.

The best thing that can be said about this movie is the characterizations. Any given scene is well-written and well-acted. In particular, Timothee Chalament’s verbal spats with the financier Milton Rockwell (played by Kevin O’Leary), Owner of Rockwell Ink, who may or may not want to be his corporate sponsor, are especially memorable. Marty Mauser also has an affair with Kay Stone (played by Gwyneth Paltrow), wife of Milton Rockwell, and they too have verbal spats. You think at some point Milton Rockwell will find out about the affair but the movie is too busy for that. I hear the Oscars have created a new category for Best Casting. I’m not sure what that really amounts to, but I would think this movie has some sort of edge given all the especially non-movie-star-looking Jewish actors in supporting roles.

The movie is too long to end up where it ends up. If I had to choose the removal of one of the sideplots, I would omit the one about the guy with a lot of cash who gets injured when a bathtub falls on his arm and he sends Marty on a mission to bring his dog to a veterinarian but the dog gets lost when Marty hustles a bowling alley with a black cabbie and there is a conflagration at a gas station, but then they find the dog at a farmhouse across the street the next day but the owner is violently opposed to giving the dog back and so various people die of gunshot wounds in a shocking and gratuitous fashion. This movie would have been better without all that if only because it would have been shorter.

I haven’t even gotten to the subplot about Marty knocking up another man’s wife, Rachel Mizler (played by Odessa A’Zion) and her being like eight months pregnant during some of the more violent scenes about the dog. But what does it matter? What was the point of this movie?

It is not that I am discouraging the subject matter. Good Time was about a petty criminal, but then he met someone even stupider than he was and by the end of the movie, it felt like he had turned a corner. Uncut Gems, though the main character was reckless and adulterous, had an ingenious scheme to turn himself and his gambling debts around. It was exciting to see him try to pull off. What is the redeeming value of Marty’s story? Josh Safdie misses his brother. Benny may have been able to come up with something.

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

The Avengers (3/5 Stars)

It’s Okay!

 I never read comic books as a kid nor did I have a ton of video games, but I did own action figures, mostly Star Wars and Legos. Action figures, unlike books and video games, do not come with their own story lines so kids had to use their imaginations in order to have fun. I do not recall any particular story of mine that is worth repeating suffice to say they all had one thing in common: continual cartoonish violence. You know the kind where you take two action figures and you harmlessly smack them against each other and make kablooie noises. I remember it fondly in that odd nostalgic way people tend to glorify the stupidity of children (or innocence, either one), but I would not insist on making a feature film out of it, which, I would argue is essentially what “The Avengers,” is: A story composed of the kind of action sequences I would have come up with when I was ten years old....and had access to several hundred million dollars.

Don’t get me wrong. “The Avengers,” is okay and I must admit I haven’t the slightest idea how they could have made it better. It seems fated to be mediocre due to the cast of characters that are included. The Avengers are composed of Iron Man/Tony Stark (played by Robert Downey Jr.) a genius mechanic/billionaire who wears an indestructible suit that can fly and has plenty of machine guns and missiles. Then there is the Black Widow/Natasha Romanoff (played by Scarlett Johansson) who is good at martial arts and uses pistols. Then there is Hawkeye/Clint Barton (played by Jeremy Renner) who is good at archery. Then there is The Hulk/Bruce Banner (played by Mark Ruffalo) who is a brilliant scientist who involuntary turns into an uncontrollable green monster with unlimited strength whenever he gets angry. Then there is Thor (played by Chris Hemsworth) who is an immortal demi-god with an all-powerful hammer that can summon lightning storms. Finally, there is Captain America/Steve Rogers (played by Chris Evans). He has a patriotic uniform and a nifty shield. It should be fairly obvious that these superheroes aren’t exactly equal. I mean Captain America may be strong, but not as strong as the Hulk, and he can’t fly like Iron Man, and he has no ability for stealth like the Black Widow, and he has no long range ability like Hawkeye, and he isn’t educated like Bruce Banner or Tony Stark. In fact, he really doesn’t know anything about the last fifty years because he was cryogenically frozen during that time. (He is otherwise their leader though.) Contrast that with Thor, who as an indestructible and immortal god should be able to beat the tar out of every other Avenger in every scenario. The presence of a superhero such as Thor also requires the story to have a super-villain with an almost equal amount of power as him. Enter his brother, the semi-god Loki and an army of mean-looking aliens with supposedly superior technology.

The movie stages two rather huge battle sequences. One takes place on a flying aircraft carrier (largest waste of taxpayer money EVER) and another in Midtown Manhattan. Besides the death of one person, it may surprise you that nobody else gets seriously hurt or dies. No superheroes, no military personnel, and no civilians end the movie with anything more than the faintest scrapes, cuts, or bruises. In fact, I would argue the greatest special effect used during the full scale destruction of a completely inhabited Manhattan is the framing of the shots in such a way that we never actually see anybody getting hurt. This sense of total unreality is what reminded me of playing with plastic toys as a kid. Nothing is real. Otherwise Tony Stark would be dead ground meat in his fancy suit after every battle he is in. And can the Hulk really survive a multitude of rockets launched point blank into his face without a single blemish occurring?

 For some reason it has become increasingly difficult for blockbusters to achieve the very reason they exist: to excite and thrill. It is not hard to have violence that is exciting. It simply must include actual danger or actual pain or the threat of actual pain. To demonstrate how little you need, take a look at the movie, “Black Swan.” In particular, the scene where the main character notices a cut near her nail cuticle, tries to fix it, and accidentally pulls off a strip of her skin. When I watched that it made me recoil. Why then would Thor knocking Iron Man 100 feet into the air with his magic hammer have little to no effect at all? Well, because it results in nothing but a dazed look. It must not have hurt. A movie with action sequences that have no effect on the characters is not exciting. It is desensitizing. Pretty soon it does not matter how big the explosions are, all I recognize is their impotence. What is more, when I do not understand how things happen, I stop caring pretty soon if they happen at all. I don’t get how Iron Man can survive all the blows he takes. I don’t understand how The Hulk can beat up a floating leviathan one thousand times his size. And will someone please tell me how the hell Scarlett Johansson can beat up burly men three times her size. She has no muscles. None.

 I suppose some of this has to do with the MPAA. There is this strange rule out there that allows PG-13 movies all the gunfire, explosions, and metropolitan destruction they want just as long as you do not see anybody getting hurt. However, if you wanted to see a man realistically cut off his own arm like James Franco does in “127 Hours” you would get an R rating. In effect, violence is morally okay just as long as you don’t show the consequences of it. Oh, will someone think of the children. They are our future. But unreal hammed up violence is not in itself bad. I’ve seen plenty of movies I loved that worked just like that. The best of director Robert Rodriguez (Sin City, Planet Terror, Machete, Desperado) excels in that sort of thing. The difference though is that these movies are fun exploitation movies that don’t give us a bunch of scenes containing impassioned speeches about the importance of it all. “The Avengers,” needs to be more uniform in its purpose. If you are going to make the action sequences ridiculous then make the characters and dialogue ridiculous, and do it the whole way through. And please no intended-to-be-taken-seriously-patriotism. This country deserves better than that. “Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol” was a great action movie. So, for that matter, was “Black Dynamite.” “The Avengers,” works best when it treats itself like it should: a joke. There are enough self-referential and belittling jabs that make the movie pretty funny throughout its run time. Quite a lot of these are provided by the best character, Tony Stark, played brilliantly as always by Robert Downey Jr. Mark Ruffalo, the nth incarnation of Bruce Banner, does a solid job as well. I still wish Thor’s weakness was stupidity and not arrogance (see my review of “Thor”) and I never saw Captain America’s movie so I guess I missed the part where it makes sense for our symbol against Nazism be a guy that looks like the poster child for Aryan machismo. Scarlett Johansson and Jeremy Renner like most interesting actors continue their star rising descent into less interesting movies.

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Contagion (3/5 Stars)




Setting a record for the number of Oscar Winners killed in throwaway cameos.

The potential of a worldwide epidemic has been a great time-waster/audience scarer in the news for the past couple years. The virus will come from China (SARS, Birdflu) and just might be comparable to the 1917 influenza epidemic that killed about 1% of the world’s population. That was 1917, so the number of dead was only in the millions. Still, what if a virus like that came along again. Hundreds of millions might die.

“Contagion,” tells the story of such a virus in an oddly responsible way. There are no gruesome death scenes, over-dramatic wailing, or contagious zombies roaming the earth. Instead we are treated to plenty of scientists and doctors saying scientific things with patience and composure. These scientists are played by such acting heavyweights like Laurence Fishburne, Kate Winslett, and Marion Cotillard. The first victim of the virus is Gwyneth Paltrow. Matt Damon plays her grieving husband. There are several other small parts played by well known actors. Jude Law plays a sensationalist blogger intent on dispensing government conspiracies. John Hawkes plays a janitor in Laurence Fishburne’s office. Jennifer Ehle and Demetri Martin are two other scientists working on the vaccine. Finally there is Bryan Cranston who plays some sort of military officer. Obviously, this is a very impressive cast. There are four Oscar winners, two Oscar nominees, and a two time Emmy winner in it. But none of this really matters except in marketing. You can put all the famous great actors on a screen and it still does not guarantee a great movie. This is especially true if the story is trying to be realistic.  

What’s the point of a Great Actor if the story does not allow for Great Acting? The Oscar winners here are supposed to be playing normal people going about exactly what they would do in this situation. This calls for understated performances, which they all do quite well. But really, it probably would have made more sense if the movie didn’t have any big name stars at all. Celebrity has a way of overshadowing underdeveloped characters. I rarely felt I was observing actual people. More often I was like, well, look that’s Kate Winslett and now she is in Chicago. Furthermore, if the movie wanted to take a realistic take on a subject that involves the entire world and a hyperlink network of characters, then perhaps the movie would have been better if it weren’t a movie. Two hours is not long enough to tell this story the way they want to tell it.  It should have been a 10-hour HBO mini-series.

The fact that the movie has such a huge scope but is only two hours long gives the story a sense of being in fast-forward most of the time. The vaccine apparently takes several months to create and distribute in the movie, but has a screen time of about 15 minutes. The great heroine of the story, Jennifer Ehle, is barely in the movie at all. Character back-story and motivation is hinted at but never developed in a satisfying way. Most of the problems set out are solved off-screen or dissipate in large jumps in time. Weirdly enough, the most dramatic conflict in the storyline is not the virus at all. It deals with the sensationalist blogger played by Jude Law who I think was selling a fake cure online. He gets arrested at the end, or maybe not. I’m not sure what was going on there in that park or even who he was talking to. It all happened so fast.

We’ve all seen catastrophe movies before. Well, remember that scene where the people are running wild in the streets and the looters raid the supermarket. That scene is in this movie too. Now, I’m sure that such a situation can be told in a realistic way that is just as exciting and dramatic as these scenes are in the best of zombie movies. But when a movie does not add anything to the set up the scene will not escape cliche. Time and details are needed for a realistic movies to be exciting. Otherwise they lack credibility. Now they obviously were pressed for time in this case, but whittling away those details makes what is left rather humdrum. Without the credibility the scene actually comes off worse than the same scene would be in a not so serious movie. You take the supermarket scene in a movie like “Zombieland.” Not only do they raid the supermarket, but they also kill zombies. Here they just raid the supermarket. It's boring.  

Having said all this, the movie is well put together considering that it is telling a story about a worldwide catastrophe in such a short running time. The director is none other than Steven Soderbergh, who was the Oscar winning director of one of the best hyperlink movies ever made, Traffic. But, really, you can just sense all the talent in the direction and the cast here going to waste. One wonders why Soderbergh decided to make this movie at all. The man is capable of great things. Why is he wasting his time with mediocre projects? Actually you can say this about Soderbergh’s career in general. Did we really need an Ocean’s 13? Come on Steven, you’re better than this.



Sunday, October 24, 2010

Iron Man 2 (4/5 Stars) May 29, 2010

Less funny. Better action. Just as good as the first.

I’m going to throw something out there that might be a little controversial to fanboys. Perhaps Iron Man 2 would have been better if there was no such thing as Iron Man. Imagine what this movie could have been as simply an intense rivalry between two egotistical, charming, nutty, arms manufacturing CEOs played by Robert Downey Jr. and Sam Rockwell. There would still be plenty of witty dialogue, arrogant machismo, gear-head porn, and explosions galore but less to distract from all of that like glitzy special effects sequences that involve battle suits whose functions and limits I don’t fully understand. I mentioned in my review for the first “Iron Man,” that I found Tony Stark more interesting outside of his suit than inside of it. That continues in this movie. I think the problem was that I was never sure how protective the Iron Man suit was. Would bullets actually penetrate it? How badly did it need to be hit before Stark became hurt? It seems that it could be thrown through walls and it wouldn’t affect Stark at all. I don’t know if bullets actually would hurt it. Plenty were thrown around but I don’t think a single bullet from any gun hit any target in this movie. After awhile the sound of machine guns sort of gets redundant. I don’t recall the last movie I saw when the bad guys weren’t shooting blanks. 

The movie was directed Jon Favreau and written by Justin Theroux. Both are mainly recognized as actors but do a competent job here. The inspiration in this movie has primarily to do with casting. If you want to hear me gush over Robert Downey Jr. see my previous review of “Iron Man.” I also particularly like Sam Rockwell as his business competitor, Justin Hammer. Together I suppose they could be called the Kings of Nuance. Both have this incredible ability to insert odd rhythms into their speech that can really liven up the conversation. I was very glad that the movie gave each of them plenty of lines. I can listen to these two all day long, it was just too bad that they didn’t have more than one conversation with each other. It could be said that normal people don’t talk like these two. But then again, megalomaniacal arms manufacturing CEOs aren’t normal people. One of my favorite moments in the movie is when Sam Rockwell opens his keynote speech at the Stark Expo by doing a nutty little dance up to the podium. I love that dude. 

The story has two main conflicts. One is that Tony Stark is dying. The core that is keeping him alive is also poisoning his blood. The Second is that a disgruntled Russian named Ivan Vanko (played by Mickey Rourke) believes Tony Stark’s father stole his father’s idea for the iron man suit. He is out for revenge and has a pretty cool suit for himself. There’s also a side story that involves an eye-patch wearing Samuel L. Jackson who seems to be recruiting Robert Downey Jr. for another sequel. I’m sure anyone who has read the comic books will know what that is about. I didn’t but it didn’t particularly bother me.

The laughs in Iron Man 2 do not come as early as they do in Iron Man, but after a half hour through the film they start to pick up. The makers do a good job of keeping up a screwball pace to the dialogue and the actors are eminently capable of throwing the lines back and forth. There is a particularly great scene where Tony Stark attempts to apologize to Pepper Pots for several arrogant indiscretions. Stark’s attempt reminded me of the Dude trying to explain the new shit that had come to light to the Big Lebowski. It really is perfectly delivered. 

For the reasons stated above, the best action scenes are those that don’t involve the Iron Man Suit. I particularly liked Ivan Vanko first battle with Tony Stark in which he chops his racecar in half on the Monaco speedway. More impressive though was Scarlett Johansson’s fight scene in which she beats the crap out of about ten much larger dudes. It was the first time I have seen a movie put in the effort to debunk the ‘Implausibly Tough Girl’ cliché. (For reference sake the Implausibly Tough Girl is any woman in an action movie who has the extraordinary ability to disable men twice her size simply by knowing kung fu. This hard to believe discrepancy occurs because we like our action women in a certain paradoxical way. We want them to match our standards of beauty i.e. be very thin, buxom, wear lots of makeup, etc. but also possess the ability to kick-ass. Of course someone who is very thin will also naturally be very weak. That’s why it’s implausible. Because it happens all the time makes it a cliché.) How “Iron Man 2” does this is something I advocate all the time. They show the action sequence in long enough shots so the audience can tell exactly how Scarlett does it. I’m still not sure the physics made complete sense but I did actually see it happen. In one scene she manages something related to a scissors kick to grasp Jon Favreau by the neck and throw him to the ground. I was impressed. I’m very much looking forward to what Scarlett will get to do in the next movie. As far as I remember the first movie didn’t have any hand-to-hand combat, something I will always find more entertaining than the consistently ineffective use of machine guns. For that reason I’d say the action in the second is slightly better than the first. In short, the movies are about the same caliber and are worth seeing. 

I should also mention a small part of Garry Shandling as a Senator who repeatedly fails to get Tony Stark to give over the Iron Man suit to the United States. He plays the type of hapless person you would think he would play and is consistently funny in doing so.

Iron Man and Oscar Talk 05/05/08

Are special effects really that special anymore? Maybe we should just call them effects from now on. I bring this up because there was a hell of a lot of razzle dazzle in this movie. All of it state of the art blow up your mind computer generated effects, but I must be desensitized to it by now because I found myself more interested by Robert Downey Jr.'s Tony Stark without his mask then with it. 
Robert Downey Jr, by the way, kicks ass. He's an overall really cool guy, I think it was really awesome that he got to be cast as a super hero. I think it says a good thing for the genre that they are hiring dudes like Downey Jr. He's not really a huge bankable star, he just happens to be perfect for the role. He's always had this way of pointedly spitting his words that makes his characters seem very wacky or very smart and usually both. His character, Tony Stark, the millionaire playboy genius arms dealer extraordinaire is a walk in the park for Downey Jr. You can tell that the dude is having a ball playing this guy. Robert also looks the part so much also. He's not a big guy, but he's got the strut and he looks like he knows he's smarter and cooler than everyone else and to his credit he probably is. 

Tony Stark's always capable assistant is Pepper Pots, played amiably by Gwyneth Paltrow, who somehow won an Oscar way back when and hasn't done much since. This part I think could have been played by any number of actresses. How do I know this? Well, because I saw this same part in the 2006 Casino Royale movie, except that girl was played by Eva Green. A different shade of this woman has shown up in several movies lately. All you need is a pretty face who can exchange witty banter with a small sly smile. 
There are a couple of things in this movie that seem somewhat recycled. The parts where Stark was learning how to fly reminded me of Spiderman's and Batman's first attempts. Then there's that one action sequence where Iron Man fires a rocket, turns around, and walks toward the camera very cool like as a tank behind him explodes. Very cool shot yes, but I already saw it in a couple of movies now. Bardem in now 'No Country for Old Men' comes to mind. It worked best with George Clooney in 'Syriana' I think. One cool thing that I felt was original was Stark's robots. They infused the machines with personalities, and the way that Downey orders them around garners a good amount of laughs. 
The only real problem this movie has though (at least to people who don't watch a lot of movies) is its villain, played by Jeff Bridges. The bad guy isn't explained enough I feel. I never understood why he did those bad things, or tried to bump Tony Stark. It probably would have been a better idea if they didn't try to make it a big twist like they did. That way, the character wouldn't have to constantly lecture Stark while he's trying to kill him. I thought we were past this cliche in the movies, but we have the Talking Villain in this movie. Where the bad guy could kill the good guy if he just shut up and did it. 
It's a good idea to pay attention to why the villain needs to talk. He needs too because there has to be some reason for him to be bad, and the story up to that point didn't provide any. Obadiah aka evil bald dude turned bad within the span of five minutes of screen time. He had to pause during the fight sequences to lecture Stark just so we weren't completely confused as to why he would want to kill his best friend. It wasn't hard to discern that Obadiah would be the bad guy. I would suggest that they don't even make it a secret next time. Just make it clear he's the guy from the beginning, give him more screen time and more purpose, and help us understand the story a little better. 

It has come to my attention that I didn't do my usual Oscar opinions for this last year. I meant to but just didn't get around to it. Anyway my top five movies this year were as follows in no particular order: 
Superbad (another great one from producer Judd Apatow)
No Country for Old Men (Saw it a second time and thought it was brilliant)
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (Tim Burton's best)
Into the Wild (Beautiful adaptation)
My Kid Could Paint That (stranger than fiction documentary)

I didn't think there were any real depressing steals or upsets from the Oscars. I was glad the Bourne Ultimatum got recognition, thought it cool that the Coens finally got their best picture trophies, understood the acting awards (although I thought Blanchett should have one supporting actress and Wilkins best supporting actor). I thought director Joe Wright should have been nominated for Best Director, that was I felt the biggest snub. Cinematographer Roger Deakins too I believe should have an Oscar by now. Other than that, I thought it was a great year for movies. Congrats to everyone who was nominated and won.

Running With Scissors 04/20/07

This movie starts out like this: (Blackout) Maybe this is how I should tell the story of my life (paraphrased somewhat.) 
Bad news bears alert! Do you know what you're doing or not? You don't know where to start this movie? Maybe it should start like this? We need a little more confidence here in the tale. Why even a voiceover? just start it: This is what happened. Authoritative, direct. Don't waste my time, figuring out what you're trying to do at the beginning. 
This movie suffers from a more mild identity crisis. It tries to be a comedy, but there's nothing funny about a true story like this. Sure one can insert humor in here and there as comic relief but don't expect me to laugh at these poor poor people. They easily win my pity not my scorn. Mental illness of course can be very serious. Especially when you're mother is seeing an even crazier shrink who drugs her out of her mind in order to adopt her kid along with his monthly child support check. Throughout the movie we get the sense that author is somewhat afraid of people's reactions. So he puts up this fence to show that he himself is above the entire mess. He makes it known and clear to the audience that this movie is supposed to be funny. Which wouldn't be a problem if what really didn't make people laugh is someone telling us outright that we should. Like I said before this movie needs more confidence. Not just in themselves but also in the audience. They need to trust that we will want to find the story interesting or funny. Is that not why were here watching the movie? Paticularly in the first quarter the movie holds our hands a little too much. It gets better though.
We have good performances all around. Most notably from the adults, Cox, Bening, and Baldwin, who seems to be in every movie nowadays. The younger charachters not so much, but then again there's not much to them and its probably pretty hard to play a homosexual schizophrenic as if you know what you're doing. 
The director's ability is somewhat in flux also. Again toward the beginning. He loves doing interesting things with the camera sure and I respect the ambition but there's a reason we have an editing room. Like bad jokes in comedies, if a montage doesn't work or has no purpose than it shouldn't be in the picture. We have quite the montages in this film, slow motion, pop music, fast-forward, snow from the ceilings. About three quarters of them work. Another quarter doesn't. Where's that asshole producer when you need him.
Is this is going to turn into that review that bashes the picture the entire time but then recommends it. Unfortunately yes. Why? Because as I said, it has problems. But three fourths of the time it works, and the story is more interesting and ambitious than most of the stuff out there. So while it may not have reached its perfection as a story, the goal was set up high and a failure at this level is respectable.