Search This Blog

Friday, April 27, 2012

Five Films Series: The Hunger Games

Five Films Series: The Hunger Games

Smile! You're on TV!
You do not have to look very hard to find real life parallels in this spring's smash hit, "The Hunger Games," in today's oversaturated culture of "reality" programming. (i.e. The sensationalism, the unfair behind the scenes manipulation of supposed fair contests, the shamelessness of it all.) But try not to be too clever about it. In my last five films series I attempted to show the transformation of a topic over the years. In this article I will attempt to show the opposite. I will show a topic, media sensationalism, that I argue has not changed at all, technological advances aside.

This is a provocative topic, especially in the media. You don’t have to go very far to find some TV, newspaper, or radio pundit complaining about how the mainstream media is biased and sensationalized. And they are correct in one aspect; media in general is biased and sensationalized. (They are also very wrong in another when they claim that there is such a thing as a uniform “mainstream” media. If you are a pundit that has a big enough audience, you are automatically a part of the “mainstream” media and if other people in the “mainstream” media do not agree with your point of view than logically the “mainstream” media is not uniform.But that is beyond the point of this essay.) But it always has been and using five great films from the past I hope to at the very least dispel the notion that there once was a nostalgic “golden age” of honor in the press. I also hope to point out some of the inherent idiosyncrasies of the medium of film and television that tend to stray the news to bias and sensationalism even when the people behind the news have the best of intentions. And maybe just maybe I might say something about human nature.

1940 – His Girl Friday, directed by Howard Hawks


A manager of a newspaper learns that his ex-wife and ex-star reporter is engaged to be married to an insurance salesman. So over the course of the day he pulls out all of the stops (legal and illegal) to get her to stay on for one more story in an attempt to break up the engagement and get back his love, and just as important, his best employee. The character of the big newspaperman was rampant in early cinema. They were either adventurous crusaders or dirty sensationalist manipulators or both (Citizen Kane?). Walter Burns is his name in this movie (played by Cary Grant) and he is the epitome of the latter. Whatever he is doing in this story, it sure isn’t ethical journalism. Witnesses are goaded, conclusions are jumped to, and lying and scheming is usual business. When revealed, more lying and scheming comes follows, just in louder shouts and with less shame. In fact, at several parts, in order to delay the departure of the couple, Walter Burns, goes so far as to frame the insurance salesman for several crimes and thrown in jail. Then he kidnaps his mother. Really.

The big newspaper story the movie centers around the imminent execution of a cop killer. The newspaper takes the cop killers side and plays the angle that the killer was insane at the time and that the politicians are ignoring that fact because the cop was a “colored” man and they are trying to capture the “colored” vote. (It is always a sad thing when you watch great old movies and something racist casually pops up.) Was the guy really crazy? Well, that’s debatable. The point of course is that the newspaperman cares less about the story than using the story to further newspaper circulation and get back his girl. It’s all a means to an end to him, and he couldn’t care less if people are getting run roughshod over while it happens. Walter Burns is a big strong confident man that talks super fast and lives his job. He does not have time for pauses and self-reflection. Tomorrow’s paper needs to be done by tonight and it has to be better than every other paper in town.

What makes this movie a great movie is that his ex-fiancé can match the big newspaperman, line for line, and snarky remark for snarky remark. The rapid-fire dialogue in, “His Girl Friday,” is perhaps the fastest ever seen in any movie made then and probably since. (At least I haven’t seen a movie with faster dialogue.) Generally speaking, a page of dialogue in a screenplay represents about a minute of screen time. Reports from “His Girl Friday,” had them fitting four pages in a minute. It is a rather incredible thing to watch. Here is the entire movie, FOR FREE!

1951 – Ace in the Hole, directed by Billy Wilder 


We tend to share a glorified memory of the 1950s built on lots of nostalgic movies made in the 1970s and 1980s, but watching the movies actually made in that decade make me wonder whether it was actually one of the worst decades in our history. You cannot match even today the cynicism and bleakness of an average 1950s movie, the golden age of hard heartless men and loveless untrustworthy women. Everyone smoked and drank nonstop and, let’s face it, was probably suffering from some intense untreated PTSD leftover from two huge wars mixed in with a very present threat of a potential nuclear war.

One of the more cynical movies is “Ace in the Hole,” a story about the disgraced journalist Chuck Tatum, (played by Kirk Douglas) fresh fired from several big papers out east and finding himself in a remote town in New Mexico working for the local rag. He hates it there and hopes for that one big story that will rehabilitate his career and get him the hell out of the dump. Then one day, it happens. There is a cave-in at the local mine and a man is trapped inside and can’t get out. An Ace in the Hole! Chuck Tatum knows exactly how to milk that story for everything it is worth. The only problem is that if the local excavation team does the job properly, the trapped man will be out in two days. Not good. Chuck needs at least a week of fresh sensational newspaper reel to turn the story into a full-fledged media circus. So he convinces the local politicians and police to have the excavation team drill from the top (which will take a week) instead of coming in from the mouth of the cave itself. How does he do this? He promises to right glowing reviews of the politicians and police about their response to the emergency. The man’s wife is in on it too. She hates the small town as well and thinks her husband is a loser for choosing to live there. She cheers up only when tourists start filling up her restaurant as they stop by to gawk at the mine. She starts charging them admission tickets in order for them to park their cars on her lawn. Meanwhile, in the mine, the trapped man slowly starts dying.

Pundits get “outraged” today by simple video edits of telephone calls or YouTube videos that take things out of context. But this sort of thing has been happening forever and it is a curious thing to get angry at what seems to be a natural occurrence. It should be remembered that until very recently in history, newspapers or any other type of media did not even attempt to pretend to be objective. It is said that the entire Spanish-American War of 1898 can arguably be credited to lies perpetrated by the newspapers of William Randolph Hearst. Since this is not a new thing the question of why reporters enrich their stories with unreliable evidence or fabricate them entirely should not be asked without the obvious counterpoint, why are they so continually successful? As Chuck Tatum says, “Bad news sells best, because good news is no news.” Once again, here is the full movie, courtesy of YouTube.

 

1976 – Network, directed by Sidney Lumet 


Howard Beale, the widowed, fatherless, hard-drinking anchor of the UBS news hour has just been fired for low ratings. Since, as he says on air during his next to last night on the program, that he has nothing left going for him in his life, he plans to commit suicide during the next show. “You ought to get a hell of a rating out of that. 50 Share, Easy.” Predictably, the ratings skyrocket, but not before Beale is fired for calling life bullshit (instead of apologizing as he was supposed to do) on his final night. Behind the scenes though is a producer named Diana Christensen, who lobbies to bring Howard Beale back on air to yell bullshit some more because obviously it is what the people want to hear. Think of the ratings! “For goddsakes Diana, we’re talking about putting a manifestly irresponsible man on National Television,” says the head of the news department. She nods. Exactly.

This is the heavyweight movie in this series of films. Network, is one of the best written screenplays ever, the best evidence being that almost every actor that spoke the words ended up with an Oscar  nomination (a record five total) with three winning (Peter Finch for Best Actor, Faye Dunaway for Best Actress, and Beatrice Strait for Best Supporting Actress). The influence of “Network,” can be seen in many news networks today and in weirdly the absolute wrong way it should have been. Howard Beale, the mad prophet of the airwaves, is almost a venerated figure nowadays, with plenty of pundits (Glenn Beck comes to mind) actually seeming to draw on him for inspiration, and at least one recent politician from New York who used his catch-phrase, “I’m Mad as Hell and I’m not Going to Take it Anymore!!!” in a campaign. What must be remembered though is that Howard Beale is quite literally an insane person and he is not on air because suddenly the news division at UBC cares about the “truth,” or “telling it like it is,” but because they have realized they can draw a gigantic profit by putting on a show with almost no production value (basically a guy shouting bullshit with no actual investigative reporting) and selling it to an audience, angry because of a depressed economy and a high crime rate, that simply wanted somebody to articulate its anger.

At the same time, and this I must admit, Howard Beale is almost impossible to take one’s eyes off. He is an unforgettable character with several memorable passionate speeches (Finch won a Best Actor Oscar for what is essentially a supporting role). The sophisticated amongst us will tend to look down upon the sensationalized portion of our media. We will belittle the TMZ’s, the Reality TV shows, and the Angry Talking Heads on the 24-hour networks, but this overlooks the fact that these shows are sometimes genuinely entertaining (not informative, but entertaining). Here’s a good example. Take a morning and listen to AM Radio, Rush Limbaugh, why not? He is after all, one of the best. Notice how he talks with as much fervor and passion during his advertising segments as he does when he talks about politics or the news. This should tell you something about the show. The fact that he is always so provocative no matter what the subject is should be seen as having less to do with his actual feelings than what can be said is a professional style. Words spoken are generally more exciting when spoken with righteous indignation, and his job is to be exciting, not so much to inform. It is okay to enjoy these shows, just as long as you aren't actually relying on them to be informed. No, you should not be watching Jon Stewart's "The Daily Show," for news value. It isn't news. It's entertainment. Perhaps someday I will write an essay on how one can tell which they are watching at any given time.



1987 – Broadcast News, directed by James L.L. Brooks 


But let us stop being so cynical for a moment. How about a movie with nice likable characters that only want to do the right thing. I give you “Broadcast News,” one of my favorite movies and a perfect demonstration of why television probably cannot be trusted with the truth even with the best of intentions behind it. This movie was directed by James L.L. Brooks and is based it on his own experience at a news station. It is about a producer named Jane Craig (played by Holly Hunter) who is fighting the good fight of substantive journalism over flash sensationalism with her colleague Aaron Altman (played by Albert Brooks) a veteran reporter and an expert on everything that reporters should be experts about. Entering the station one day is Tom Grunick (played by William Hurt) who freely admits that he is not a good reporter nor very smart, but is probably the best choice for anchor. What he has people cannot teach. He is good looking, poised, and a really nice guy. Unlike Aaron who is not so good looking, snarky, and increasingly bitter and mean that he is being overlooked and underappreciated.

Admittedly, this is more of a story about people than a satire on the news (there is a love triangle), but what concerns us is the news. There are several things I would like to point out. First of all, the news is a deadline driven business. At the same time is an art form. So it follows that no matter how prepared everyone is, everything is still always rushed, because a news piece can always be made better with the time gained from good preparation. (See clip below of Joan Cusack running through the newsroom to make a deadline with her famous huge 80s hair.) The profession is exhausting and should only be considered by workaholics. Secondly, and here is the tragic thing. It does not matter how hard you work or how well the writing is, or how informative the report is, if it cannot be presented well. The success of Tom Grunick does not come from any scheming of his, but because he is likable. Whereas Aaron Altman fails even though he knows everything and can write anything because he does not like people, and in turn, is not liked by them. When Aaron finally gets the chance to anchor the news one night, he writes a very good monologue about a very important event. Unfortunately he starts sweating profusely on the air. Nobody in the audience even noticed the story. All they saw was a guy sweating a lot. In essence, you cannot present any story whatsoever on the news if you cannot make a good first impression. You need flash without distractions first. Substance comes later. Hopefully you can find a really good-looking person to anchor your newsroom who has the latter. This is presented persuasively in this movie by Oscar nominated screenplay and three Oscar nominated performances (Holly Hunter, Albert Brooks, and William Hurt). It is also a very funny movie and probably the most enjoyable of the five here.


2007 – The Fifth Season of “The Wire,” created by David Simon 


The Fifth Season of “The Wire,” is commonly known as the disappointing anti-climax to what “some people” say (and by that I mean me) is the best thing ever shot with camera. Anti-climax? Sure. But, disappointing? Not so much. To say that would be to glean over what exactly the makers were trying to say about the first four seasons. That would be: if we know what the problem is, why can’t we solve it? Enter the press room of the now defunct Baltimore Sun, facing cutbacks and low morale. It has on staff a couple of producers that are more interested in finding a better job at a better newspaper instead of making the newspaper that they are at competent and functional and a young reporter that is sensationalizing his stories instead of putting in the effort to do real journalism. The ultimate irony: every great story being told, all the important issues, all the fantastic characters in the series are completely missed by the newspaper as they chase a fictional serial killer of homeless people down in hopes of scoring a Pulitzer Prize. I can’t show you any of “The Wire” here on YouTube nor can I really ask you in good conscience to watch an entire TV series in a single article. But here is the creator, David Simon, speaking before Congress about the future of newspapers and his disdain for bloggers. It should be the least interesting part of this article, but probably, by far, the most informative.



I will see you in the dystopic future, where I am sure we will continue to have the same neverending problem with the media.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

The Hunger Games (3/5 Stars)



The Reality TV Paradox

Great documentaries are lucky documentaries. The greatness of such films like “Hoop Dreams,” or the “Seven Up” series rely greatly on the unlikely coincidences that somehow were recorded by a camera. Would anybody have cared about the Rolling Stones documentary “Gimme Shelter,” if it did not just happen to accidentally chronicle a murder at a rock concert? Would the mockumentary “Borat” be as hilarious if Sacha Baron Cohen had not coincidentally hitchhiked onto that particular RV filled with those particular outrageous frat boys?

Now at the same time imagine that you were a movie or television studio that is attempting to create a documentary that will be predictably successful. How can you produce a predictably successful product that relies on coincidence? If you don’t do anything you are at the whim of fate and the documentary will either be bad or good depending on what you so happen to record. But if you do things to make sure that dramatic coincidences do occur, you are essentially writing the documentary, which in essence makes it cease to be a documentary. In the end, like much reality TV, you get a product that lacks dramatic effect because unlike real documentaries it is untruthful and manipulative and at the same time lacks the production value and professionalism of a documentary that is sincerely untruthful and manipulative, or in other words, a fictional movie.

I bring this up because, “The Hunger Games,” is a fictional movie about a reality TV show, and as such piles on layers of almost absurd complexity on how the characters are perceived depending on whether it is by us the movie audience, or the TV audience in the movie. In other words, the underlying emotions of a scene are generally undermined by the realization that it is all an act. And how much can you care about a person (even if it was a life and death situation) if you knew they were mugging at a camera at the same time?

I have given this movie three stars because I enjoyed it okay. But I want it also to be known that I have never seen a movie quite like this one, and that affirmation of originality should be seen as a sort of moral victory at least. The story takes place in a future where the United States has split itself into 12 districts and hosts an annual game that pits two randomly selected teenagers from each district into a fight to the death gladiatorial tournament. From district 12, there comes the 18-year-old Katniss Everdeen (played here by the 25-year-old Jennifer Lawrence) who volunteers for the tournament to save her 12-year-old sister from being selected. Also selected from her district is Peeta Mellark (played by Josh Hutcherson). They are whisked away from their poor coal-mining district to the big city where they are mentored by Haymitch Abernathy (played by Woody Harrellson) to be likable, because that is the best way to win these particular games. In other words, the games are not real. They are fake reality TV. Apparently a good old fight-to-the-death would not be predictably exciting enough. There is a whole behind the scenes room of producers here who manipulate the games. This can be done by releasing forest fires or releasing lethal wild animals into the tournament space whenever they feel it will add some spice. The most blatant form of cheating is to get sponsored. If you are “likable” enough, the head sponsors will send you a parachute containing a survival kits that can give you an edge over the competition. In other words, the “Hunger games” are bullshit. And to play into the whole “getting people to like you” survival game, Katniss and Peeta pretend a romance. This is original in that it is the central love story of the movie, and admittedly, I have never seen a movie so willingly and transparently admit that its central love story is contrived bullshit.

I suppose we are now at a point of idiotic media saturation where the only way to seem truthful is to exert the highest amount of cynicism. Everything about “The Hunger Games” is fake. The games are fake. The capital city that the games take place is composed of fake 3D generated architecture. The hairstyles and fashion of the inhabitants are grotesque, garish, and nonsensically exaggerated. (Actually I would admit this is perhaps some of the best effects of the movie. Whoever designed the costume and makeup had a field day with this movie. It is done much better than the action and done so well, that at least three quarters of this movie could be deemed a chick flick.) Every other tribute in combat is a one-dimensional stereotype whether it is the evil Cato (Big Evil Guy) or the innocent Rue (Small Innocent Girl). In fact, the only distinguishable human being seems to be the main character, Katniss Everdeen, played by Jennifer Lawrence, who when you think about it, may be the fakest character of all.

Oh boy, what did I mean by that? Well, Katniss is the type of person that does not like to bend toward conformity or try to get people to like her. She just wants to be herself. Now, whom does that remind you of? If you said you and only you, you’re an idiot. That should remind you of everybody. That description describes everybody. In fact, I would argue that Jennifer Lawrence’s best acting asset is her ability to act blank slate and call it individualism. This character has no foibles or eccentricities. It is just Jennifer Lawrence in her plain/beautiful persona having strong feelings for her family and a survival instinct. You would be hard-pressed to find a human being with neither of those characteristics. Do you think it just may be the best marketing ploy ever to take this one-size-fits-all persona and throw it into a story with so much fakery that it seems real by comparison? It would appeal to every person who feels that they are the only real person in a world of phonies (which I would argue is a real cliché way to feel).

The phenomenal success of “The Hunger Games,” should lead to some hilarious movie studio board meetings. I can just see it now: a bunch of middle aged rich guys brainstorming on how they can capitalize on a trend based on the utter distrust of manipulative media because it is ruled by a bunch of middle aged rich guys bent on manipulating people for profit. Vampires were easy. Now I suppose we will have a slew of movies made expressly for profit that aim to expose cliché and promote distrust in manipulative money-grubbing movies. It’s a shame that irony can’t kill. 


Monday, March 26, 2012

Five Films Series: “Django Unchained”

Editor's (that's me!) Note: This article was written for the website HalftimeHennessy.com; you can check it out there as well....


In 1994, the preeminent black filmmaker Spike Lee had a good question for Hollywood. Who does this white guy Quentin Tarantino think he is, using the N-word a half a hundred times in his movies?  Tarantino shot back that he was first and foremost a writer before he was a white man and this granted him the right to have his characters speak like real people spoke, period. Looking back, he was probably right, I mean, when is the last time someone saw “Pulp Fiction,” and thought it was racist. But at the time, it was rather new to have the word said at all, and especially to have the phrase "dead n***** storage," said so frequently. It was definitely something that would not have been okay twenty years before that.

Well, have you heard what Tarantino’s next movie is about? It is a “Southern,” starring Jamie Foxx as an ex-slave on a mission to free his slave wife from an evil plantation owner, played by Leonardo DiCaprio. Samuel L. Jackson co-stars as the complicit head house slave. This is kind of revolutionary. Every movie in the past that came even remotely close to American slavery always treated it in this very serious and dramatic way. In contrast, this will be a Tarantino film. That is, it will probably be rather enjoyable to watch. In preparation for some great cocktail party discussions this winter when the movie comes out, here are five films that will make you an expert in race relations, at least where movies are concerned.

  1. Birth of a Nation (1915), Director D.W. Griffith

 Every discussion about race in movies must start with “Birth of a Nation,” a movie that revolutionized movie storytelling in both technique and technology, broke box office records, and is arguably the most virulently racist movie ever made. The first hour and a half is a civil war movie. The action sequences were great back then but by today’s standards, kind of suck. I suggest skipping ahead to 1 hour twenty minutes when Lincoln is shot in the head. The really astonishing stuff gets into gear right afterwards during Reconstruction, a time in which the North occupied the South with an army and freed blacks gained citizenship and the rights that went with it for a brief period of time.

 “Birth of a Nation,” tells an alternate history. One in which The Ku Klux Klan was started as a measure of self-defense when ex-slaves started bullying white people at the voting booth and making unjust rulings against whites via all black juries. The irony is overwhelming and may suspect the viewer to awful pain-inducing laughter. Others play like some sort of bizarre hallucination, like the surreal scene of a session of congress composed of all black senators with their bare feet upon their desks eating chicken and drinking whiskey. My favorite though has to be the hurt look on whitey’s face when a black guy has the audacity to walk past him on a public sidewalk. Oh the injustice!

 Perhaps the most ridiculous thing about this movie is that apparently the makers didn’t think they were being racist. D.W. Griffith actually testified to that belief. But that’s like saying it’s okay to say the sky is green because you really believe that it is green. At some point self-delusion becomes unforgivable. For instance, it is this movie’s argument that the ex-slaves were content with slavery and that they were basically tricked and goaded into wanting rights by northern carpetbaggers. There are even some (loyal) ex-slave characters in this movie that think having these rights is really stupid and a truly unforgettable scene near the end of the movie when they actually fight back against their fellow African Americans on behalf of the really nice white folk.

 Now let’s talk about sex. One of the more peculiar things about “Birth of a Nation” is its lack of black actors. Quite a few of the black characters are actually played by white people in blackface. But not just any blackface. It is poor blackface so the audience can easily tell that it is not actually black people playing the black roles. Well, that’s odd? Why would they do that? Well, for one thing, the plot calls for black men making sexual advances on white women (at one point a white woman actually commits suicide by jumping off a cliff to get away from a black pursuer). Apparently it would have been way too outrageous to have an actual black person to leer at a white woman, even if it was only a movie. 

Since it is now public domain I am including the movie in its entirety here. I consider it a must-see movie first as a cultural education on insidious effects of racism and second as a baleful of incredulous laughs. It certainly wouldn’t be in good taste, but if you structured a drinking game around taking a shot whenever something astonishingly false or disgustingly offensive happens, you would probably get pretty wasted pretty quick.

 

 2. Gone with the Wind (1939) Directed by Victor Fleming, George Cukor, and Sam Wood 

 In 1939, the epic Civil War blockbuster “Gone With the Wind” became the highest grossing movie ever made, a title it still holds when one accounts for inflation. It also has several things in common with “A Birth of a Nation.”

 It should be noted first of all that unlike “A Birth of a Nation,” “Gone With the Wind” is still a movie worth seeing simply as a movie. Whereas the action sequences in “Birth” are piss-poor by today’s standards, the set pieces in “Gone With the Wind,” are still effective and at least one, the zoom out of the battlefield wounded, is as masterful as ever. The character development and story arc are helped as well by ditching the ludicrous excesses of historical inaccuracy that plague “Birth.” But in terms of race, one aspect of “Birth” is still very present in “Gone With the Wind,” and that is a complete omission of anything negative about slavery and several black characters that are weirdly loyal to the main characters. This is represented in an idyllic representation of the slave plantation known as Tara. It is an unquestioned good place in the antebellum part of the movie, and when it is destroyed during the war, it is no doubt a very tragic thing. The slaves in this movie just might agree if anyone bothered to ask them or cared what they thought about it.

 But even so, for its time, the movie could be considered a step in the right direction. The character of Mammy, at least in the way Hattie McDaniel plays her, is a strong no-nonsense woman and generally speaking the smartest person in the room. None of the other characters seem to notice of course, that is except the societal outcast, Rhett Butler. At first look, the character may seem rather one-dimensional given that she spends the entire movie cranky and cantankerous, but I don’t know, if you were a slave, maybe you’d be pissed off all the time too.

 In 1939, Hattie McDaniel became the first African American to be nominated and win an Oscar, beating out her fellow white cast-mate Olivia De Haviland in the same category. The Academy recognized as the best supporting actress of the year and then made her sit apart from everybody else in the cast and crew at a segregated table.

 

 3. In the Heat of the Night (1967), Directed by Norman Jewison 

 “In the Heat of the Night,” may not be widely seen today but its influence is still felt in cineplexes every year. Have you ever seen that movie where an odd couple of police officers are assigned to the same case? Maybe at first they do not even like each other, but over time they gain each other’s respect and by the end catch the bad guy on equal terms. Well, “In the Heat of the Night,” was the first of such movies and literally invented the sub-genre. It went over so well, in fact, that it won the Best Picture Oscar in 1968.

 Sociologists will confirm that the working together of people on an equal level is what breaks down prejudice, whereas if you had a master-servant or boss-employee relationship, it would only reinforce notions of superiority/inferiority. Here is a very entertaining example of exactly that happening.

 The black man is played by none other than Sidney Poiter, who in the sixties basically was at the center of his own subgenre of movies that were expressly aimed at breaking down racial prejudice. Sidney was just the black man to do it. He was handsome, well dressed, well spoken, educated, polite, and had the whitest freaking name in the world. Basically he was everything society said the ideal white man should be except he was black. So either you liked him or you admitted you were a racist. Sidney Poiter starred in several of these kinds of movies, but “In the Heat of the Night,” is the most entertaining of them as it has both sex and violence. If you want to be bored by a movie of great cultural importance, you can watch “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner?”

 

 4. Do the Right Thing (1989), Directed by Spike Lee 

 Spike Lee’s “Do the Right Thing,” is a landmark for racial-conscious movies not just because it was the first written and directed by a black person, but for also who the primary audience was for it. In other words, the previous movies on this list were all aimed at white people, whether or not it was to reinforce their views or to change them. “In the Heat of the Night,” is about a white racist sheriff. He is the one that changes in that movie. Sidney Poitier is a supporting character in that arc as far as I’m concerned. (I argue that you can say the same thing about the black characters in such recent movies as “The Blind Side” and “The Help.”)

In contrast, “Do the Right Thing,” is not about white people. It is about a black community that is confronted with racism both personally (for example, the N word) and more importantly institutionally (for example there isn’t a single black-owned business in a neighborhood that is 90% black). Racism in “Do the Right Thing,” is a given. The question presented for discussion is what should black people do about it?

 Spike Lee makes such a question deliberately hard to answer. The story takes place during the hottest day of the year, encompasses an entire neighborhood’s worth of colorful characters, and draws out a domino chain of cause and effects from little slights (why does a pizza place in a almost entirely black neighborhood have an exclusively Italian hall of fame) to grievous errors (a police officer’s use of a very controversial type of chokehold hold on an arrested subject), that slowly but surely accumulate into a night of racial violence prompted by the action of a character that has good reasons not to do and to do what he eventually does.

 One other thing to notice: When white people make race-conscious movies in a non-racist way, it tends to bring out the Sidney Poitier in black people. One example is comeuppance, a sort of comedic affirmative action. It is a technique whereby a racist joke is generally followed by the minority scoring a little victory or the offender looking foolish in some way. Another technique is balancing. Say you were to have a really stupid black character (like say Tracy Jordan on “30 Rock”) In order to not be racist, you can include a really smart black character in the story as well (like say the Harvard man Twofer on “30 Rock”). Or you can have true plausible deniability by being racist to every race in your movie (South Park, Harold and Kumar, the list here is pretty large). Or finally if you were really pathetic and your name was Michael Bay, you would lazily have non-white minorities make stupid racist jokes at each other to create the thin illusion that no white people were actually involved (Bad Boys II).

 But since “Do the Right Thing,” is made by a black person it allows the black characters a greater license to be flawed three-dimensional humans. There isn’t any fear that a viewer would mistake the character’s personality to be the black writer’s view of all black people. For example, perhaps a white writer (who isn't Tarantino) would have hesitated before making the character of “Buggin’ Out,” such an asshole.
 

 5. Crash (2005) directed by Paul Haggis

 I end this essay with “Crash,” the best picture winner from 2005. Watching this movie alongside the other four I think really demonstrates just racism has changed the last 100 hears. In many ways “Crash” can be seen as sort of a post-racial movie in that every single character in “Crash,” is aware of racism and knows that it is a bad thing. Politicians even wheel and deal with the knowledge that people are judging their actions in terms of race. Weirdly enough this provokes them to make decision explicitly based on race, like for instance giving a police promotion to a black man in order to not look racist when they are arresting a disproportionate amount of black people.

 Just for fun, “Crash” expands the race dialogue into a more culturally diverse realm where everybody on earth is involved and it is not merely just a black and white thing. And as a hyperlink movie, we get about 15 main characters which intersect each other’s stories whether by purpose or coincidence or by crashing into each other’s cars. In the meantime they all take turns being racist in that relatively benign way that we are nowadays (and by that, all I mean is that I’ve watched “Birth of a Nation.”)

 “Crash” is a special movie for me because it actually changed my thinking about certain things. In particular, there was this one scene where this non-racist character (who I of course identified with the entire movie) makes a snap judgment about another character and ends up shooting him. In that scene, there had been an argument and the non-racist character thought the other person was reaching for a gun, when in reality he had been reaching for something predictably innocent. Thing is, in the moment I was watching the movie, I thought that the other guy was reaching for a gun too. And if I were to be totally honest, I probably would have shot him too. Shows what I know about not being racist.

 

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

John Carter of Mars (2/5 Stars)


Really expensive nonsense


“Only enormously talented people could have made "Death to Smoochy." Those with lesser gifts would have lacked the nerve to make a film so bad, so miscalculated, so lacking any connection with any possible audience. To make a film this awful, you have to have enormous ambition and confidence, and dream big dreams.”
-       Roger Ebert

The explanation of why "John Carter of Mars" exists is better than the movie itself. It’s director Andrew Stanton is best known as one of the great creative forces behind the golden age of Pixar. He was a cowriter for all three Toy Story movies and directed both “Finding Nemo,” and “Wall-E.” To a movie lover like me he is arguably one of the greatest living directors and I would put “Wall-E” on a list of the 100 best movies ever made. To studios he represents enormous profits, both “Toy Story” and “Finding Nemo” having broken box office records for animated movies. So when Andrew Stanton came to the producers at Disney with an idea for a science fiction/comic book movie with lots of violence and exotic locations, who in their right mind would say no. They granted Stanton full access to the Disney playground. $250 million dollars later in production value and $100 million dollars later in marketing produced the movie that last week grossed only $30 million and is destined to be one of the biggest flops of the year. What went wrong? Well, for one thing, the movie isn’t any good. But how could that happen? (See above). There are two main problems both of which could have been solved by a cigar-chomping asshole producer with only dollars for eyeballs. Those people are good for something.

The first big problem is way too much faithfulness to the source material. This movie is based on more than a century old comic book series. In this book we are introduced to made up weapons, made up languages, made up peoples, made up places, made up cultural customs, made up powers, made up gods and goddesses. Everything is nothing I had ever heard of before. When a character dramatically intones that they have to find the ninth ring of iths from the gates of Barsoon before the tharks release the giant white ape and the thurns shapeshift for the red man blue man widget marraige at Helium, my reaction is like, “Huh? What?” And this sort of thing goes on for much of the movie. They keep throwing in new shit, giving no explanation or time for it to sink in, and then expecting big dramatic payoffs. A very big problem has to do with the story’s technology. People in flying warships are fighting with swords while big green men on the ground have calvary and guns. Then there are these other dudes that have the ability to shapeshift and vaporize anything within a few seconds using a blue widget thingy. I haven’t the slightest idea what that thingy is or why nobody else has it or why it was not used in the battles far more often. This movie could have been a lot shorter if the blue vaporizer thingy had not been used so sparingly. Then there is John Carter himself, a civil war veteran from Earth, transported to Mars via a little thingy, to find that his Earth muscles provide him with superior abilities on Mars’ lower gravity. Basically, he is super strong and can jump really high. But how high can he jump? The movie is very very unclear about that. At points it is just a few meters, but at other times it could very well be a football field. It is this critics opinion that for action sequences to be effective, the laws of physics must be followed, even when it is on Mars, or if they are to be bent they are bent in a clear and predictable manner (See “The Matrix.” Do not see “Matrix Reloaded” or “Matrix Revolutions.”) Otherwise nothing makes sense and the story’s momentum and suspense deflates. The suspension of disbelief gone we are merely witnessing an actor in a weird costume skipping around a room with a green screen.

That actor would be Taylor Kitsch a remarkably bad choice in casting whose responsibility for the failure of the movie is only somewhat alleviated by the even worse choice of Lynn Collins, as the Martian princess. Put these two together and you have some of the most horribly acted scenes I have seen in a long time. And you cannot merely just say that the material was arcane and stilted. Sure they are speaking about weird lore and strange happenings but that still doesn’t forgive the utter lack of excitement or range in the performances. Let’s say a horde of green Martian barbarians was descending upon you for the express purpose of killing you. Perhaps your facial expression and body language should suggest you were doing anything other than posing for the Mars version of GQ magazine. Or consider John Carter’s reaction to learning that he is on Mars for the first time. That Taylor Kitsch reminded me of a young Keanu Reeves, and that is about the worst compliment you can give an actor. One of the producers of this movie should have required that Andrew Stanton cast a well-known action star as the lead in his $250 million dollar epic. This is not simply a cynical attempt at more dollars via a better marketing platform. “John Carter of Mars,” is Stanton’s first live-action movie. He had never worked with actors before. If the director casts unknowns who do not know what they are doing, guess who has the responsibility to teach them what to do: the director. And if the director does not know how to direct actors and the actors do not know how to act, what you get is this silly drivel, made even sillier as it is being performed against a backdrop of a ridiculously expensive, intricate, and extensive amount of costume, makeup, CGI work, set design, and production value. What a colossal fuck-up this was.

I keep thinking back to that other live action foray by an acclaimed Pixar director, Brad Bird’s “Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol.” Whatever similar problems Bird may have had were alleviated by a familiar and franchised story that took place in present day and was anchored by Tom Cruise, who is, private weirdness aside, quite frankly one of the best actors in the business, and may very well be the best action actor. For future studio reference, the next time a great director wants to spend an extremely large amount of money on something he has never done before with a bunch of inexperienced collaborators, it might be a good idea to sign him up for two movies and make the first one a much less expensive test run.  


Friday, March 9, 2012

Wanderlust (4/5 Stars)


This can't be the place

“There is a reason that human beings long for a sense of permanence. This longing is not limited to children, for it touches the profoundest aspects of our existence: that life is short, fraught with uncertainty, and sometimes tragic. We know not where we come from, still less where we are going, and to keep from going crazy while we are here, we want to feel that we truly belong to a specific part of the world.”
-       James Howard Kunstler, The Geography of Nowhere


The ending of “Wanderlust” is a cliffhanger, although I suspect most people (and perhaps even the filmmakers) will not realize how. The story itself follows a married couple named George and Linda (Paul Rudd and Jennifer Aniston) as they search for a home that is “real,” for lack of a better word. They start out in Manhattan, a place that demands endless toil to make barely enough money for a sizable mortgage on a very small studio apartment. When George loses his job during a massive corporate layoff, the city unceremoniously ships them out in favor of richer people.

George and Linda move down to Atlanta to live with Rudd’s boorish brother Rick, played by co-writer Ken Marino. Rick is the CEO of a port-o-potty company and lives in a McMansion out in a suburban nowhere. The house may be huge and filled to the brim with really expensive stuff, but the desperate housewife Marissa, played by Michaela Watkins, soon reveals that she spends most of her day alone and drinking margaritas. She has a theory that if she smiles enough it can brainwash her mind into feeling happy.

George and Linda escape to stumble upon a commune out in the middle of the woods. It is filled with colorful characters that smoke pot, grow organic vegetables, and share everything. At first this lifestyle is infatuating but it soon wears off because of the complete lack of privacy (there are no doors to the bedrooms or bathrooms), the annoying veganism, and the free love atmosphere that basically acts as a masquerade for Seth, the leader of the commune, played here by Justin Theroux, to hit on all the women that move in.

So that place does not really work out either. But the movie does end on a happy note with the characters getting new jobs and moving into a new place with happy music all over the background. The place is bigger and friendlier than the Manhattan studio, not as fake and isolated as the McMansion, and has actual doors. But where is this “real” place? We are never actually told. Is it anywhere in America? Because seriously, I think most of us would like to live there. It does exist somewhere, right?

The ambiguity of the ending of “Wanderlust,” is what stops the movie from achieving great movie status like director David Wain’s last Paul Rudd movie, “Role Models.” The special thing about “Role Models” is that behind all the jokes about the nerdiness and weirdness of the Dungeons and Dragons community known as LAIRE, there was a sincerity that held up the group as very creative and really fun to be in. Taking part in that community redeemed the cynical Paul Rudd character in the end. That cannot be said about the bohemian commune in “Wanderlust,” as they are shown to fall into the same hypocritical and selfish habits of all people no matter how vehemently they claim that it is not allowed there. The ending is a bit of a deux ex machina, a miracle that basically saves everyone from dealing with the main problem of the movie by making them all too rich and successful to care anymore. So this is not as satisfying as “Role Models.” But it is basically just as funny and employs just as large an ensemble of great comedic characters.

You’ve seen these actors before if you saw “Role Models.” Coming back in supporting roles are Kerri Kenney and Jordan Peele as the some of the hippies. The incomparable Joe Lo Truglio once again performs the feat of creating a complete character within thirty seconds of screen time. He is the commune’s nudist/winemaker/novelist. I suspect the reason why I found the ending forgivable is because it is this guy’s miracle. Joe Lo Truglio seems to be the kind of guy who could pull that off.

(It should be noted that creative freedom for full male frontal nudity has finally been achieved in this movie. When I saw this sort of thing in “Forgetting Sarah Marshall,” it still seemed like they were still trying to hide it by quickly cutting away. In this one, there are no quick cuts, and for some weird reason the fact that the movie does not seem to be afraid to have little Joe Lo Truglio just hanging out there for extended periods of time actually makes the whole thing less distracting.)

Then finally there is Ken Marino who reprises his role as a very funny asshole. He is joined this time by Michaela Watkins, an old (she’s 40) newcomer on the comedy scene. The comedic dynamic that these two create is the sort of thing that makes you wish the movie visited the McMansion more often. Watkins in particular is very very funny. You may remember her brief one year tenure as a featured played on Saturday Night Live, where she was funny in basically every scene she was in and then was inexplicably fired the next summer. I am glad she is now popping up in feature movies, but really, someone who cares about comedy ought to see this movie and start granting her more screen time doing anything in any other movie. She is the real thing and talent is a-being wasted while Eddie Murphy still gets to make a horrible movie every single year.

As far as Paul Rudd is concerned, he continues his now five year string of anchoring at least one good comedy in a year. (Wanderlust, Our Idiot Brother, Dinner for Schmucks, I Love You Man, Role Models.) That’s a good streak and he is a very good leading man for comedies. His humor is nice, subtle, and normal. This enables the plenty of wacky other characters around him to be crazy and all he has to do is twitch his face the correct way to round out the scene.

I still do not know what to make of Jennifer Aniston as a comedian. She has been in some great comedies and done some very good work (Office Space, The Good Girl, and Horrible Bosses), but she has also been in a string of really bad not funny movies. Oftentimes her characters lack the eccentricity needed to be funny and spend most of their time looking out of place while everybody else gets laughs. There is a part in this movie where the movie stops being a story about a couple and starts being a movie about Paul Rudd. Were missing something here. There has got to be a better way to make Aniston interesting besides having her take her top off, especially since it is blurred out anyway. Back to the drawing board on that one. Learn a thing or two from Michaela Watkins and Kristin Wiig on how to make women funny. Here is a link to one of their SNL skits for educational purposes.  http://www.hulu.com/watch/56640/saturday-night-live-today-show





Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Oscars 2011



In the long view of things, the movies have two purposes. One purpose is cultural reflection. The movies hold up a mirror to society, and through them we honor the truth of us, whether beautiful or ugly. The second purpose is that of escapism. This assumes that we know the truth and would rather not deal with it for a couple of hours. Both are legitimate purposes, but it has been the tradition of the Academy to honor truth not escapism. The Oscars generally deal with gravitas, choosing movies such as “The Hurt Locker,” over “Avatar,” or “Schindler’s List” over “Jurassic Park” or “Annie Hall” over “Star Wars.” And in a way this makes sense, because choosing truth over fantasy is the adult thing to do. Whether we liked the Academy’s choices in the past or not, we could at least say that they were taking their job seriously.  That is until this year.

This year we had some great comedies and great action movies that spoke truth. There was a rare combination of wit and real life and action with gravitas. Annie, the heroine of “Bridesmaids” saw her small business fail.  A trio of working men confronted with “Horrible Bosses,” could not quit because they feared they would not be able to find other jobs. A physics teacher and family man turns to an Ultimate Fighting tournament in order to save his house from foreclosure in “Warrior.” An army marine stationed in Afghanistan is sent on a mission to stop an impending terrorist attack in “Source Code,” reminding us that yes, we are still at war. And a harmless but “Idiot Brother” is imprisoned in exchange for a charitable act involving marijuana reminding us that, yes, after all this time, we still have idiotic drugs laws.

All of these were great movies that came out this year and they all have something in common: the Academy completely ignored them. Instead they heaped nominations on “Hugo,” something the director Martin Scorsese freely admits is a movie for children, “War Horse” a war movie that hides the horrors of WWI under a PG-13 veil, “The Help,” a story of how several hardworking African American women helped a young white girl write a best-seller, and that most infantile of movies which glorifies the cinema’s baby years, “The Artist.” “The Descendants” was at least modern, but how many people can say they face the problem of either keeping their vast tract of prime Hawaiian oceanfront property or selling it for millions upon millions of dollars. Oh those hard choices. If it wasn’t for Billy Beane in “Moneyball,” trying to figure out how to win a championship on a shoestring budget we could definitely say that the Academy apparently was not around for the last three years.  I am of the opinion that “Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close,” was not nominated because it was a movie (it wasn’t), but as yearly tribute to Harvey Weinstein.

If I were to choose a movie to sum up 2011 it would be “Take Shelter,” a drama by Jeff Nichols that contains such stunning truth about employment, health care, gas prices, the weather, etc. it could best be described as a horror movie. But perhaps I would be better off choosing Woody Allen’s “Midnight in Paris,” as it is about nostalgia and explains pretty well why there were so many mainstream movies set in the early 1900s this year. (Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, Midnight in Paris, War Horse, The Artist, Hugo, A Dangerous Method, The Adventures of Tintin, let me know if I forgot any)

Anyway, as I’ve said before, the best part of being a movie critic is that you are never wrong. Here are my Oscar picks for this year. They are correct because they are “MY” Oscar picks, not yours or the Academy’s. If you want to be correct, go write your own picks down.

First of all there are those categories of which I have no clue how to judge and for which I intend to spare you of my ignorance.

Best Sound Editing, Best Sound Mixing, Best Makeup


I have also not seen any movies that could be up for the following Oscars.

Best Documentary Short, Best Animated Short

Then there is that category, "Best Song," whose rules need to be rewritten or dumped entirely. In the last decade perhaps only two great songs were ever nominated for an Oscar ("Lose Yourself" by Eminem for 8 MILE and "Falling Slowly" for ONCE). Generally the nominations are almost by default as original songs are incredibly rare. So I propose we make the category Best Use of a Song, and in so doing can honor those moments in movies where the proper music can really elevate a scene.  

Best Use of a Song
“Hold On” by Wilson Phillips from BRIDESMAIDS
Insurance Parody of “Oh Holy Night” from CEDAR RAPIDS
“Immigrant Song” by Led Zeppelin from THE GIRL WITH THE DRAGON TATTOO
“About Today” by The National from WARRIOR
Christmas Melody from A VERY HAROLD AND KUMAR 3D CHRISTMAS

Spoiler Alert for the video!!! Don't watch if you do not want to find out who wins the climatic fight! I strongly suggest watching the movie first as it was one of the best of the year.




Plenty of people hated "The Tree of Life." to an extent that really surprised me. Sure, it was disconnected and confusing but even if you did not understand a single scene, was it not just goddam gorgeous the entire time. Here is the trailer without the voiceover, just the music. Try to enjoy it.


Best Original Score
The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn - John Williams
The Artist - Ludovic Bource
Take Shelter - David Wingo
Tower Heist - Christophe Beck
The Tree of Life - Alexandre Desplat




Again, ditto what I said for the last one. Have some faith and just go with it. 


Best Cinematography
Drive - Newton Thomas Sigel
Meek’s Cutoff - Chris Blauvelt
Midnight in Paris - Johanne Debas and Darius Khondji
Take Shelter - Adam Stone
The Tree of Life -  Emmanuel Lubezski



Best Foreign Film
Ip Man 2

Admittedly, I only saw one foreign film this year, but it was certainly good enough to win an Oscar.



Best Documentary
Conan O’Brien Can’t Stop
Hot Coffee
How to Die in Oregon
Into Eternity
Tabloid

Weirdly enough, two of the best and more important documentaries of the year, "Hot Coffee" and "How to Die in Oregon" are not eligible for the Oscar as they had debuted on HBO. This is one of the Academy’s main problems as HBO has in recent years routinely churned out better movies than most feature films seen in theaters. It makes no sense not to honor some of the years best simply because they were shown  first on TV (see "You Don't Know Jack," and "Temple Grandin"). Anyway the two HBO documentaries were perhaps the most important, but you cannot say they were the best made. That title belongs to "Tabloid," Errol Morris' funniest documentary to date.



One of the weirder snubs this year occurred in the Best Animated Feature category where the fantastic "The Adventures of Tintin: Secret of the Unicorn" was omitted due to it being considered a live action movie. Take a look at the trailer below and see if that makes any sense whatsoever.


Best Animated Feature
The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn
Cars 2
Rango



I remember a couple of years ago, Tim Burton's "Alice in Wonderland," rightly took home both of these Oscars, but the weird thing was that most of the design in that movie was digital (i.e. animated with computers). Building off of that logic, why not give the Oscar to a movie with the best design, even though it is entirely animated.


Best Costume Design
A Dangerous Method
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
Hugo
Midnight in Paris
Rango

Best Set Design
A Dangerous Method
Hugo
Midnight in Paris
Rango
War Horse




Someday Director Zach Snyder will make a great movie. "Sucker Punch," is not it, but his futuristic use of almost entirely green screen surely points in that direction.

Best Visual Effects
Hugo
Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol
Rise of the Planet of the Apes
Sucker Punch
Super 8



I may be incorrect in thinking this, but when I judge editing, I basically just go with a movie that had very complex logistics in structure and plot and yet was presented in a way that was completely understandable. "Source Code," a movie in which a marine travels through time and relives the same 8 minutes over and over again in order to find a terrorist fits that bill quite well this year. 


Best Editing
Drive
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol
Source Code
Take Shelter



How good was "Midnight in Paris?" Well, if someone who had never seen a Woody Allen movie asked me which one they should watch first (there are over forty of them), I would say it would not hurt to start with "Midnight in Paris." Here is a good moment with Ernest Hemingway. Not only is it hilarious and moving, but it really does sound like Ernest Hemingway. Now that's good writing.

Best Original Screenplay
Bridesmaids - Kristen Wiig and Annie Mumolo
Midnight in Paris - Woody Allen
Source Code - Ben Ripley
Take Shelter - Jeff Nichols
Warrior - Gavin O'Connor, Anthony Tambakis, and Cliff Dorfman


Michael Lewis had a few rather complex arguments he had about baseball when he wrote "Moneyball," in 2003 and they all centered around people making mistakes by placing a higher value on instinct over mathematics. Movies are inherently emotional, so to convey these ideas persuasively is not the easiest thing to do. However Zaillan, Sorkin, and everybody else (there were plenty) who wrote and rewrote this screenplay did a fine job of it. And they still convey the emotional side pretty good as well.

Best Adapted Screenplay
The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn
A Dangerous Method
Everything Must Go
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
Moneyball - Stevean Zaillan and Aaron Sorkin



A suppporting actor does not need to be well rounded. He is merely there to support the story. And so the one dimensional vicious arrogance of Darren Shavali british boxer is a great performance in that it provides such a strong antagonist to the humble Ip Man. The same goes for John C. Reilly's varied performances this year in movies like "We Need to Talk about Kevin," "Terri," and most memorably in "Cedar Rapids." These characters propel a story forward and fill in the gaps while the main characters are thinking and adapting. Then of course there is Andy Serkis, who performed motion capture for Cesar the chimpanzee in "Rise of the Planet of the Apes." The Academy probably does not know how to properly judge such a performance (me too). However, I am confident in nominating him because I am certain no other actor in the world could have done a better job.

Best Supporting Actor
Andy Serkis – Rise of the Planet of the Apes
Darren Shavali – Ip Man 2
John C. Reilly – Cedar Rapids
Neil Patrick Harris – A Very Harold and Kumar 3D Christmas
Viggo Mortenson – A Dangerous Method



I cannot even say that Keira Knightley had the best performance in "A Dangerous Method," but she can still rightfully win this category on any given year because it is usually so weak. This is due to most movies being about men (and thus there is stronger competition in the Actor categories) and also due to the fact that I, a man, generally see more movies about men. For example I did not see "The Help," "My Week with Marilyn," "Albert Nobbs," "Young Adult," nor "The Iron Lady" this year. I may update the actress categories when I see "My Week with Marilyn" and "Young Adult." I do not plan on going out of my way to see the others.

Best Supporting Actress
Maya Rudolph – Bridesmaids
Melissa McCarthy - Bridesmaids
Keira Knightley – A Dangerous Method
Cate Blanchett – Hanna
Jennifer Aniston – Horrible Bosses



I do not, however, need to watch those movies in order to be certain that Kristen Wiig had the best performance of the year in "Bridesmaids." It is a perfect performance both comedic effectiveness and emotional honesty, with a dash of some great physicality thrown in just for fun. Here is one of my favorite moments out of many. Let's see Meryl Streep do that.

Best Actress
Jessica Chastain – Take Shelter
Kristen Wiig – Bridesmaids
Michelle Williams – Meek’s Cutoff
Saoirise Ronan – Hanna
Tilda Swinton – We Need to Talk about Kevin



It is obviously really really hard for the Academy to appreciate physical acting. That's why Jean Dujardin's nomination this year in "The Artist" really kind of irks me. It is all mugging and tap dancing. Now that is totally fine, but if the Academy thought that was applause worthy in any other year, than Jim Carrey would have several Oscars by now. In any case you cannot even say that Dujardin did the best physical acting this year. What about Tom Cruise doing most of his own stunts in "Mission Impossible" or the UFC fighters doing most of their own fighting in "Warrior." I argue that this sort of acting takes more skill than dramatically crying on cue. Anyway since I cannot give the final Oscar to only Tom Hardy or Joel Edgerton (perhaps they could split it), I will instead hand it to Michael Shannon for his very overlooked work in "Take Shelter."

Best Actor
Brad Pitt - Moneyball
Joel Edgerton - Warrior
Michael Shannon – Take Shelter
Tom Cruise – Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol
Tom Hardy – Warrior



The job of a director is to oversee the production of a movie in a way that complements the storytelling, making sure what should be seen is actually seen and what should not be seen is not actually seen. This is hardest to accomplish in an action movie, where the logistics can be so complicated that careful and comprehensive planning are required simply to present a sequence that follows the laws of physics. When a director does not do the job well, chaos can result in the end product (see Michael Bay). But when a director pulls off the kind of action sequences that can be seen throughout "Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol," it is clear we are seeing the work of a superior director. An absurd plot put aside, "Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol" was the most and best directed movie of the year.

Best Director
Brad Bird - Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol
Duncan Jones - Source Code
Jeff Nichols - Take Shelter
Nicholas Winding Refn - Drive
Terrance Malick - The Tree of Life



When it comes to a movie for Best Picture, I like to pick one that does everything well even if most parts of it are not done as well as other movies. "Take Shelter," had a great score and cinematography but not as good as "The Tree of Life." It was written and directed with perfect precision but not with the same genius as the writing in "Midnight in Paris," or the sheer skill of direction in "Mission: Impossible." It contained great performances, maybe not as memorable as those in "Bridesmaids" or "Warrior," but still very good. In short it was second place in quite a few categories, but overall it had enough to be the best movie of the year. And to boot it was a movie of our times. I think it summed up the many dreads of this 2011 quite well.

Best Picture
The Adventures of Tintin: The Secret of the Unicorn
Bridesmaids
A Dangerous Method
Drive
Horrible Bosses
Midnight in Paris
Mission Impossible: Ghost Protocol
Source Code
Take Shelter
Warrior



I will see you at the movies in 2012.

Sunday, February 19, 2012

We Need to Talk About Kevin (3/5 Stars)




What fresh hell is this?

It is hard to talk about “We Need to Talk about Kevin,” because it is not really a movie about something. It has a fragmented structure that jumps freely around a pivotal event at a local high school in which a teenager named Kevin takes his favorite bow and arrow and lets loose quite a few notches into his fellow classmates. We see Kevin as a little child showing many warning signs of his coming infamy. And we see him in jail afterwards but only when visited by family. And we never really see the massacre as it is happening because the movie is not about Kevin. It is about his mother.

Kevin is seen entirely through his mother’s eyes, and in those eyes, he is and has been an evil bastard ever since the day he was born. He wouldn’t stop crying as a baby, he was defiantly opposed to potty training as a toddler, and was prone to sadistic pranks on his mother and little sister up until he finally murdered a bunch of people. This movie is absorbing and unsettling in its moments, but as a whole lacks an arc. There is plenty here that a student of film can learn about composing memorable shots or creating unspoken tension in a scene, but I can’t recommend the movie as a story. Enjoy it in the moment is all I can say.

Tilda Swinton plays Kevin’s mother, Eva, in a state of almost continual mental exhaustion. Several different actors at various states play Kevin, Ezra Miller most memorably as the teenager. It is anybody’s guess whom is to blame for Kevin’s sociopathic tendencies, but it is clear that Eva is more than ambivalent about being a mother, not that even she deserved a kid like Kevin. The kid seemed to hate her even before he should have known of her dislike.

As I said, this movie exists entirely in the moment, and there are some great ones here. There is a nice scene when baby Kevin won’t stop his infernal wailing and Eva actually pauses near a jackhammer on the street just so she can get some respite from the sound. Then there is this almost uncanny ability of the director, Lynne Ramsey, to make food look and sound really disgusting. Behold how Kevin makes a jelly sandwich or the consistency of the oatmeal poured into the sink. And I suggest waiting a day before eating scrambled eggs after seeing this movie. Finally Ramsey has composed some really nice shots that would look great as posters. Take the look of Tilda Swinton after she has given birth, or hiding in the supermarket, or staring at her vandalized home smeared in red paint. It is a memorable performance made pretty special by the way Swinton is framed and edited. Should Tilda have gotten an Oscar Nomination? Yes, I think she probably should have.

But as I said, the movie though unpredictable in chronological structure is predictable in the sense that the characters do not change. Kevin is always a little sociopath and the movie is just one scene after another in which he is inconsiderate and frighteningly hateful toward his mother. I do not know, perhaps some people are just like that without explanation. A pretty good question may be why Kevin did not kill his mother as well on that fateful day. Well, perhaps living the life she leads afterward, shunned by society and receiving little else but curses and dirty looks, is a fate even worse than death. Tilda sure seems to play it that way and Kevin seems smart enough to know it.