In my review of Star Wars Episode
VIII: The Last Jedi, I stated that the quality of Episode VIII would rely on
how Episode IX resolved the interesting questions that were raised. I found especially
intriguing the idea that Rey would not be related to any of the other main
characters, this usually being a prerequisite for importance in a Star Wars
movie. The idea posited was that the Force is self-balancing. In this way, a
being that was either very light or very dark would naturally bring about their
opposite at some other place in the universe. With this understanding, Luke
Skywalker felt it prudent to leave behind the force altogether in order to not
further provoke more Sith Lords.
It turns out none of this matters
or even happened, which kind of renders both Episode VIII and Episode IX
pointless, which in turn renders Episode VII pointless too. To watch this new
trilogy is to watch the most expensive interplay between bad improvisors in the
history of movies. At the very least, as things were being made up as they went
along, the contributors could have abided by the first and only important rule
of improvisation, “Yes And…” That is if you are to not have a plan, the very
least you can do is not undercut your fellow collaborators. This basic concept
is lost on the director of the Episode VII and Episode IX J.J. Abrams and the
director of VIII, Rian Johnson.
For certain movies, a warning
against spoilers is warranted. “Parasite” is a good example. Its plot twists are
nonobvious and are brought about with Hitchcockian suspense that is quite
pleasurable to experience in the moment. For other movies, warnings against
spoilers behaves more like a marketing tool. By begging reviewers to not allow
spoilers, the mega corporations involved keep away from the audience certain
unimaginative details that would be complete let-downs if revealed.
For instance, Rey is not a total
nobody as presented in Episode VIII. Actually, she is the granddaughter of
Emperor Palpatine from “Return of the Jedi”. What a let-down. That sound is the
most interesting development in Episode VIII hitting the bottom of the
dust-bin. What is more disappointing is the reason why Rey is a Palpatine. It
seems entirely do with the decision to hew as closely to the structure and
development of the plot of “Return of the Jedi” as possible. Looking back, I
don’t see why I expected anything less. After all, Director J.J. Abrams did the
same thing with Episode VII, making that movie’s plot an almost retread of
Episode IV: A New Hope and Director Rian Johnson did the same thing with
Episode VIII, making that movie’s plot structure a retread of Episode V: The
Empire Strikes Back.
It should be noted that Director
J.J. Abrams is once more complicit in the murder of billions of people. With an
amazing lack of originality, a weapon that destroys planets has been developed by
the bad guys. Mr. Abrams once more shows no hesitation at all in using this
weapon, incinerating a planet as an afterthought and not particularly caring
about treating the aftermath with the sort of respect that should be called for
amongst such an extraordinary loss of life. The movie, like all Disney movies,
is PG-13, because there is not a hint of sex involved anywhere. Even Poe,
played by Oscar Isaac, the Han Solo-ish character, is not getting lucky anytime
soon. A sad development given that he is instrumental in saving the galaxy by
the end of the movie.
There are certain things about
this movie that do not come remotely close to making sense. However, it is hard
to talk about them in a critical manner because the movie moves so fast from
plot point to plot point that it hardly matters what has just happened. “Look
Something Shiny and New,” is the name of the game here. When the original Star
Wars trilogy came out, the critics wailed about its reliance on special effects
and lack of character development. What glory days those were, when characters
engaged each other in half a minute-long conversations and military tactics,
however limited, were considered. In Episode IV, the main characters land a
ship in the Death Star and by subterfuge, loosely defined, rescued the
princess. Here, the main characters land a ship in an enemy star destroyer and the
first thing they do is come out guns blazing as if three people with blasters
could take down a gigantic ship by brute force. The original trilogy at least
gave the audience certain outs for unlikely scenarios. To experience this
trilogy without rolling your eyes you must be a total idiot.
The ending bespeaks a recent trend
in the ever-escalating stupidity of movie villains. Like the army of the undead
in “Game of Thrones”, the evil forces here are both impossibly powerful and also can be
take down with the capture of a single target. I would posit that fair fights
that are resolved by strategy are more interesting that lopsided battles won by
technicalities. But this idea is lost on the makers of Star Wars.
There is a bright spot in this
movie and that is the basically good acting of Adam Driver as Kylo Ren and Daisy
Ridley as Rey. This is helped by a storyline that gives these characters things
to do and emotions to develop. The same cannot be said for the characters of
Poe, played by Oscar Isaac, or Finn, played by John Boyega. They do not do
anything in this movie but run around from plot point to plot point. From the
promise of Episode VII, it is rather disappointing that Poe and Finn do not
ultimately have interesting story arcs. However, at least these characters had the
promise of an interesting story arc. There are several characters in this
trilogy who were introduced and then promptly forgotten. Rosie, a seemingly
important character in Episode VIII hardly shows up in Episode IX (Maybe the
focus groups found that the world was not ready for a Black-Asian romance).
Benicio Del Toro from Episode VIII does not appear at all in IX. Domnhall
Gleeson has a fate that suggests he wasn’t willing to work for more than a
week. Keri Russell literally phones it in, perhaps only showing up to work for
one day to dub the lines for her bemasked minor character. Several other
characters are introduced in this episode seemingly for the limited purpose of
introducing new series on Disney+. But is there actually a plan to make these
series or are these scenes just bait for the focus groups where the real
decisions would be made? If that series starring Lando Calrissian does not come
to fruition, Episode IX will harbor an utterly pointless scene in a few years’
time.
There is a way to plan out a
franchise and that way was ably demonstrated by Marvel over the past decade.
Not every movie in the Marvel franchise is a must-see-most-important-installment-of-the-franchise
movie. Most movies focus on a single character which in coordination with other
smaller movies build into the bigger spectacle movies every four or five years.
Star Wars has not done this. The sad thing is that it probably could have. What
really helped Marvel was its library of over fifty years of comic book
storylines that the movies could pick and choose plots from. Star Wars has a
library substantially similar to this: four decades of books written by professional
fans and blessed as canon by George Lucas. None of this material was considered
for Episodes VII, VIII, or IX. Why?
Corporate cynicism comes to mind.
The new trilogy is the same thing as the old, but with better special effects
and a more diverse cast. Why take a risk making something new, when you can
repackage the old as a presentation to international audiences unfamiliar with
the old movies. The global marketplace is where the real movie is made. My
appetite for Star Wars has officially been sated. I do not plan on seeing any
further of these movies in theaters.
