Search This Blog

Showing posts with label judd apatow. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judd apatow. Show all posts

Saturday, September 12, 2015

Trainwreck (4/5 Stars)



The first scene illustrates the delights and detriments of this movie aptly enough. It is a flashback from the 1980s (you can tell by the video camera film stock) in which a father explains to his two daughters why mommy and daddy are getting divorced. The father explains that monogamy is unrealistic and gives an example of a daughter’s favorite doll. “Now imagine,” he explains, “you can play with that and only that doll for the rest of your life. Would you like that?” His daughter shakes her head. The point is struck home but the father continues with a list of scenarios in which other dolls may be preferable to play with. First of all it should be noted that Colin Quinn plays the father. Colin Quinn is not an actor. He is a tried and true standup comedian that always plays himself. That is to say he employs no impersonations in his act. In fact this might be his first film role ever. 2nd: His delivery in this scene is funny in a standup comedian way. It gets a lot of laughs. It also however is not a realistic scene. Any other father if he had the balls to explain the unrealism of monogamy at all would not have gone on to illustrate an absurd amount of examples to get the point across. Such is “Trainwreck,” a movie full of standup comedians telling a lot of jokes that are very funny but take away in some parts the reality of the scenes. This is not a good movie in several ways but I feel I must give it four stars on priniciple given how much I laughed during it. It is a comedy.

Judd Apatow directed it. Amy Schumer wrote and stars as the titular trainwreck, a woman that drinks too much and sleeps with way too many men. The cast is composed of a lot of people who probably would not have done a movie but for this particular writer and director. In a small role as a homeless man outside her apartment is Dave Attell, another veteran stand up comedian. The aforementioned Colin Quinn plays her nursing home bound cantankerous father. Mike Birbiglia (another stand up) plays the fiancĂ© of her non-trainwreck sister. And there are a couple of cameos by John Cena and Lebron James that aren’t really cameos. That is to say Lebron James is playing himself yes but in the best friend role to the romantic lead (Bill Hader), his surgeon. It is very funny but also odd because there is the standard cameo joke: Hey there’s Lebron James! And then he just stays around for many scenes and has thoughts and feelings as if he were a real person or something. The movie tries to have it both ways and since it is mainly funny and this is a comedy it works. But it also does not work because if Lebron James is a real character than the cameo joke should not be there. In a way I am arguing for less funny right now for more slow burn impact later. It should be noted that Amy Schumer does not regularly make movies. She makes sketch comedy and before that was a stand up comedian. That explains that.

Amy (the character’s name is Amy because why not?) works for a dumb lad mag. Her strange and boorish boss, played by Tilda Swinton, assigns her to a piece about a sports surgeon because Amy has absolutely no interest in sports and thinks that they are dumb and Swinton thinks that this dynamic will lend the piece conflict and suspense. Bill Hader plays the surgeon. Over a couple of interviews they get into bed in an absurdly quick time (not really his idea). The couple does not so much have chemistry together as the scenes they are in are just consistently funny. Judd Apatow has always tried to insert an emotional center to his movie and generally succeeds in doing so (The 40 Year Old Virgin, Knocked Up, Funny People). But here it any sort of emotional catharsis generally falls flat. Let me elaborate on that a little more in a theoretical sense.

A counterintuitive side effect of the ever-expanding role of women in cinema is the ever-brighter portrayal of men. What greater paragons of masculinity can be found then in Alec Baldwin’s Jack Donaughy of Tina Fey’s “30 Rock” or (especially) Nick Offerman’s Ron Swanson of Amy Poehler’s “Parks and Recreation.” And when Kristen Wiig wrote her masterpiece “Bridesmaids,” her romantic foil played by Andy O’Dowd was a nice, smart, and mature guy. And when this year Amy Schumer wrote “Trainwreck,” she too created a romantic foil played by Bill Hader who is also a nice, smart, and mature guy. In fact, he’s a surgeon, physically attractive (read tall), and rich. And I suspect if I bothered to watch more stuff written by women there would be more examples than these four.

What does this mean? Well it is practical. As a writer it is not atypical to write the love story from the point of view of your own gender. Really, it would feel weird not to. And given that the character is generally informed by one’s own experiences it is not unusual that the main character is more complex than the romantic opposite. Given that most stories follow a hero’s journey type of format where the main character starts one way, goes through a crisis, learns something or doesn’t, and changes for better or worse, it makes sense for most of the personality defects to be on the side of the main character. It can also be said that we tend to idealize the people we are in love with playing down whatever bad traits they have and focusing on the good ones or at least the ones that make us a better person (which would also be useful to the plot).


But I have also heard many charges of sexism when this dynamic is played out in the typical Adam Sandler comedy or the the like wherein a fashionable, smart, mature woman who spends several hours in the gym everyday is interested in a fat immature slob with a fear of commitment. This speaks to a sense of masculine entitlement. Now I wouldn’t rule sexism out entirely (especially in the employment ratio of writers and directors) but am far more willing to believe that this more about many cases of individual incompetence as opposed to a conspiracy. In other words, most people are just mediocre and most romantic comedies have this dynamic because most writers are men. There is not a vast Hollywood conspiracy dictating that guys who lack amibition in business and/or health deserve perfect women. Exhibit A for this is Amy Schumer’s “Trainwreck,” in which a chubby, immature, and too promiscuous woman becomes the object of affection for a smart, successful, and talented surgeon. He’s a nice guy and not stupid so there is no particular reason for him to like the main character other than the old “Adam Sandler” reason: this is her movie. See it works both ways and we will probably see more and more of it. Perhaps it will be so equal someday that women will start to appreciate being portrayed so well the way I happen to like Fey’s, Poehler’s, Wiig’s, and Schumer’s idealistic view of guys (mainly because it is so very rare to see them that way).

Sunday, October 24, 2010

Funny People (3/5 Stars) August 26, 2009

Death by Penis Jokes! 


The third movie from Writer/Director/Producer Judd Apatow is “Funny People,” starring Adam Sandler as a rich and famous comedian who has just received news from his doctor that he has a terminal illness, a newly thinned Seth Rogen as an up and coming stand up comic that Sandler hires as his assistant, and Leslie Mann as Sandler’s “one who got away.” Rounding out a strong supporting cast are Jonah Hill and Jason Schwartzman as Rogen’s fellow standup comic roommates, Eric Bana as the Mann’s Aussie husband, and Aubrey Plaza as Rogen’s love interest. There are also an impressive number of cameos by other comics playing themselves like Andy Dick, Paul Reiser, Norm MacDonald, Dave Attell, and Sarah Silverman. Inexplicably Marshall Mathers (Eminem) also shows in one scene where he impressively rants about the annoyances that come with being a celebrity and tells an eavesdropping Ray Romano to go “Go F*** Himself.” As in ‘Knocked Up,’ Apatow’s own daughters play the children. Both of them do a good job of acting like they are Leslie Mann’s (who is Apatow’s wife) actual children. 

The title notwithstanding, this movie is not a comedy. It is a drama that happens to be about comedians. Since comedians have a tendency to draw on their lives’ tragedies to produce humor, this movie has many jokes in it. But the jokes in this movie don’t work like the jokes in a regular comedy. In a regular comedy the jokes would work for the purpose of making the tragedy somehow okay by various techniques. Perhaps the best example of a joke making DEATH okay is King Arthur’s fight with the Black Knight in “Monty Python and the Holy Grail.” A more modern example is South Park’s Kenny being murdered in almost every single episode for several seasons. These jokes take the big topic of DEATH and belittle it by absurdly suggesting that a) it doesn’t hurt (Tis’ but a flesh wound!) and b) it isn’t necessarily terminal (OMG they killed Kenny…Again!). In this movie, jokes are made about death, but they aren’t successful in belittling it. The story wants us to take George Simmons (Sandler) terminal illness seriously. There is one scene where this is especially telling. Ira Wright (Rogen) has brought upon himself to make George an itunes list of reflective songs to help him cope with the illness. Simmons asks to hear some of them and jokes about how hokey and phony the first two are. Then Rogen puts one on that is undeniably moving. George finds his mind blanking on jokes, is reminded of why Ira made the list, and angrily berates him as he storms out of the room. Let the record show that Adam Sandler can be a nuanced actor when he feels like it.

I would compare the experience of watching this movie to the experience of watching Scorsese’s “Casino.” Let me explain myself. I could tell the movie had top-notch directing, editing, casting, acting, and writing. The creators knew the material inside and out. The stand up routines that were meant to be funny were actually funny. The pathos made sense. Technically speaking, everything seemed to be fine about this movie. The problem is that “Funny People” is an especially long movie about essentially miserable characters. George Simmons is an isolated and alienated comedian who lives alone in a huge house that seems to be useful only for attracting groupies for one night stands. He has to pay Ira to be his assistant and confidante. He constantly berates him about his last name and private parts. For the whole movie it seems that George is not learning any lessons from his illness. His first act after learning he is may be well is to get back the woman that ‘got away’ i.e. he cheated on her and she left. He does this by attempting to breakup a troubled marriage. That guy can be quite a vicious clown. It simply isn’t easy to feel sorry for a rich and famous dude who lives in a mansion and treats other people like shit. 

Seth Rogen also plays against his usual “Seth Rogen” oafish confident type. Having lost a lot of weight, his character Ira Wright seems a whole ten years younger than his usual fat self. He plays the guy young, starstruck, and way over his head. If there is an arc to this movie than it is in this character because he seems to be the only person who changes any. He goes from idolizing George Simmons, to doubting him, to finally willing to throw away any perks he could have gotten career wise just to tell the guy off. It is probably a shame that the movie focused on George Simmons so much because the heart of this story is in the coming-of-age tale of Ira Wright. Seth Rogen may have struggled at the box office this year, but in consecutive movies he has acted against type in two very different roles and has performed admirably in both of them. (the other being ‘Observe and Report’)

Also worth a special mention is Aubrey Plaza who has very little screen time as a struggling fellow standup comic but gives the most memorable performance in the movie. She is introduced cynically enough. The Jason Schwartzman character, a successful comic with his own TV show, brings her home and gives Ira ten days to ask her out or he will sleep with her. Three weeks later, after Ira has only gotten a tentative date set up with her to see a Wilco concert, Schwartzman sleeps with her. Ira doesn’t get mad at Schwartzman (because hey, he said he would give him ten days and ended up giving him twenty one.). He instead gets mad at Aubrey. Here is where the movie makes an interesting choice. Instead of simply using the scene to allow the audience to get vicarious revenge on groupies who sleep too willingly with stars, the movie gives the woman an impressive and ultimately sad retort, and Aubrey knocks the scene out of the park. What we come to understand is that two fundamentally good people who may have had a chance of being together, but feel that they have to compromise themselves because they are bottom feeders in a business that seems to arbitrarily pull some people up and keep others down. It is such a sad scene. Aubrey’s performance is, in my opinion, good enough for a Supporting Actress Nomination. Sometimes one scene is enough. 

Knocked Up 06/10/07

I like to think that I can tolerate obscenity in a movie to a certain degree, be it language or sex or violence, what have you. If it helps or if it doesn't neccessarily hurt the movie. Let's say I'm Joe Pesci and I'm a gangster in Goodfellas. Since I'm supposed to be more real than likable, I'm allowed to curse all I want. It fits. When I'm Seth Rogan or any of the other charachters in the movie "Knocked Up" and I'm supposed to be in a romantic comedy where one would perhaps want the guy and girl to stay together, it hurts the movie somewhat. I honestly didn't want the career woman to marry the slacker. She's out of his league and they fight all the time. Not that a couple can't fight in a movie. It's just to use that amount of angry f-bombs, makes me feel for the characthers less. I mean how am I supposed to sympathize with the wife when she's cursing out a bouncer at a club for no apparent reason. What an asshole. I don't care if she's got problems.

There's a dual nature in director Judd Apatow's films, in that he employs the vulgar language and situations and still makes a somewhat heartfelt, emotionally correct movie. This worked exceptionally in the 40-Year Old Virgin and that was a fantastic film. It only barely works in this one, and by that I mean the overall humor and the specific performance of Paul Rudd (becoming a favorite of mine) outweigh by just a little bit the collossal obscenity and bad taste. What's the main difference: Well in the 40-Year Old Virgin we had Steve Carell as the main character. He, despite being a virgin, was a nice, clean, and decent man. He rarely sweared and when he did, it seemed like he regretted it. There was a lot of vulgar jokes but at the center we had a nice guy to sympathize with. We wanted him to get the girl. In this movie we have Seth Rogan, a vulgar man-child with no job, and few prospects. We don't want him to get the girl, in fact we feel sorry for the girl for mainly the entire film. She's stuck with this loser's child. It's hard to sympathize with the guy and when the vulgarness rears it's ugly head we have nowhere to retreat except to the semi-vulgar presence of Paul Rudd, who I feel, should definitely be the main character in Judd Apatow's next movie.

The 40 Year Old Virgin 09/21/05

Quite the movie. As a comedy it's funny. As a romance it's satisfying. My only regret is that since it had built up so much, it didn't seem to need that extra gratuitous slapstick and melodrama in the end. ( i.e. Bicycle accident) Not that that really bothered me. I just thought it wasn't needed. Cahoots to the Carell for making a sex-comedy with heart. This type of film doesn't come along that often. Quite a fresh tomato.