Search This Blog

Showing posts with label sean penn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sean penn. Show all posts

Monday, October 20, 2025

One Battle After Another (4/5 Stars)



For the first fifteen minutes of this movie, I wasn’t sure what year this movie was taking place in. The setting seemed vaguely contemporaneous, but the characters and their actions seem to exist in the 1960s-1970s. We are introduced to a domestic terrorist outfit called the French 75. Leonardo DiCaprio plays their bomb expert. The main baddie is Perfidia Beverly Hills, played by Teyana Taylor. They stick up banks and declare that the money is being used to fund black liberation and civil revolution. What they lack in a coherent plan is made up for with narcissistic delusions of grandeur.

It doesn’t take more than fifteen minutes of screen time before reality sets in. The United States Government, led by Col. Steven J. Lockjaw (played by Sean Penn), arrests if not assassinates most of them. As Perfidia is being wheeled away in shackles, the arresting officers take out their smart phones and take selfies with her. And that is how I finally understood that this was taking place post-2007. Which is ridiculous when you think about it. Because no matter how crazy you believe our politics presently is, it still isn’t as crazy as it was in the 1960s-1970s when you had real domestic terrorists bandying about the country planting bombs (Weather Underground), engaging in shooting matches with the local police (Black Panthers), and sticking up banks (Patty Heart’s Symbionese Liberation Army).

The details of terrorism morph over time. Like criminals in general, terrorists live on the cutting edge of technology and infrastructure. In the mid-20th Century, the new interstate highway system and the arrival of civilian air travel allowed criminals to complete their activities and escape with unprecedented speed and distance from traditional authorities. The government took some time to catch up, but they did, which is why we no longer have such a scourge of serial killers and international terrorists. The new frontier today is in cyberspace, but “One Battle After Another” is stuck in the past. I am informed that Writer/Director Paul Thomas Anderson adapted this screenplay from a 1990 book by Thomas Pynchon titled “Vineland”. That would make sense, because the conceit of the movie would play much better if the prologue had taken place in the 1970s and the rest of the movie took place at the turn of the nineties.

Still here we are. Countering the 1970s vibe of leftist extremists, we are introduced to a very Reaganesque vibe of right-wing conspirators. They call themselves the Knights of St. Nicholas, gather in expensive tunnels beneath a California suburb, and seem to concern themselves solely with fighting the equally fictitious French 75. Col. Steven J. Lockjaw is presented with an opportunity to join this fabled league of white supremacists but encounters a difficult problem with a background check. You see, Col. Lockjaw had an affair with Perfidia Beverly Hills and the child she bore around the time of her arrest, could either be his or Leonardo DiCaprio’s. If it is his, he will have to dispose of this child. If not, well, its not that big of a deal, but I think the plan is to kill her anyway.

As is usual in the USA, the idiocy of delusional left-wing extremists fuels the excesses of the more formidable and much better funded right-wing kind. If the French 75 create an annoyance akin to a housefly, the Knights of St. Nicholas provoke a solution akin to swatting the same with a baseball bat. Col. Steven J. Lockjaw creates a false emergency to utilize his military force to infiltrate a small town in Northern California to search for his potential daughter, now about sixteen years old, named Willa (played here by Chase Infiniti). Colonel Lockjaw uses the army – not a SWAT Team, not a cadre of FBI agents – to search for a private citizen. He interrupts the prom of a local high school with a squadron of soldiers armed with assault rifles. Then he detains and interrogates the children to find Willa. (A very good performance is given by James Ratterman as the main army interrogator. He has very good screen presence and I was not surprised to learn that he is not an actor. He is an actual retired army interrogator.)

This is an extraordinary crime and fuels a chase around Northern California in which the French 75 abduct Willa to save her from Lockjaw, who relentlessly chases after her, all the while Leo DiCaprio tries to find his daughter and save her from everybody else. Meanwhile, the false emergency concerns an underground trafficking pipeline of illegal immigrants from Mexico. This pipeline is conducted by Sensei Sergio St. Carlos (played by Benicio Del Toro) who moonlights as a karate instructor while upstairs/downstairs of his dojo illegal immigrants sleep on mats. With all the crazy Americans on both extreme sides of the political spectrum around, Benecio Del Toro has done well to immerse himself in the calming stoicism of eastern philosophy. I am reminded of the hustler in Sean Baker’s “Prince of Broadway” whose illicit store on Canal Street is raided by the authorities and who, in the next scene, tells an employee to stick around because he will have something else going on in a few weeks. He just takes it in stride. I can only imagine what real illegal immigrants think of our cultural conflagrations. I presume it is not so different. After all, for every day they get to work and earn money in this country, they are playing with house money.

All these characters are well drawn, and the movie moves along at a fair clip. Del Toro and Sean Penn put in good work. Sean Penn is the type of movie star who seems to lose and gain inches of height between roles. Here he is at his shortest. Leonardo DiCaprio, more than anything, is a very good tastemaker and producer. He lends his star quality, no better or worse in this movie than in others, to get the movie made, which are always interesting stories told by very good filmmakers. He seems to be going through the list of all the best directors of his generation and will at the end have worked with most of them. I hear he will be working with Damien Chazelle next on an Evel Knievel biopic. I bet that one will be good too.

What can we say about Paul Thomas Anderson? He is one of the best moviemakers around and has quietly over a few decades has produced a kaleidoscopic portrait of California at varying times and places. (The sole exception is Phantom Thread which could exist just to confirm that P.T. could locate his movies anywhere if only he felt like it). It would have been a bit more interesting if he hadn’t changed the temporal setting of the book or at least updated the crimes and criminal outfits to fit the 21st century. For instance, there is a lot of crime being enabled by the dark web and Bitcoin. Wouldn’t it have been better if this movie was about that sort of criminal network. But maybe we don’t quite understand how that works yet. There isn’t that clarity that comes only with hindsight.

 

 

Monday, November 29, 2010

Fair Game (3/5 Stars)

Wait, wasn’t this supposed to be about WMD’s?


On January 2003, President George W. Bush gave his State of the Union address. That speech contained these sixteen words: “The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa.” One man, former ambassador to Niger Joe Wilson, found those words rather disconcerting. Why? Because he had been sent on a fact-finding mission to Niger and had concluded that the supposed sale of yellowcake uranium was nonexistent. He told the administration exactly that. But here it was presented as fact in the President’s biggest speech of the year. A big speech made even more important because it presented the administration’s case for the Iraq war. He called the State Department and they confirmed that when the President said Africa, he was talking about the supposed sale in Niger.

But this movie isn’t about that. It’s about what happened after Joe Wilson decided to call out the White House by writing a NY Times Op-Ed piece titled, “What I didn’t find in Africa.” The administration responded by doing a rather curious thing. They revealed in a national newspaper that Joe’s wife, Valerie, was a covert CIA operative. This movie is about her job and how she lost it, the media circus around it, and how it almost destroyed her marriage. The movie claims that the whole Valerie Plame debate was simply a diversionary tactic that distracted everybody from the real topic: why the administration felt that there was enough evidence to state in the biggest speech of the year that Iraq had tried to obtain uranium from Africa. In a way the administration has succeeded even in this very friendly pro-Wilson/Plame movie. We get hints as to why the administration did what they did, but it is never clearly stated. In the second half of the movie, that part of the story is all but lost. The focus becomes the marriage. We have become distracted.

In a way I am being unfair. Since this is a story based on real events and real people, it would probably not be entirely ethical to have an actor play a character named Karl Rove and have him saying, “I did this because…” If the makers of the movie don’t know, they certainly shouldn’t put words into the mouths of real people. But then again, this is a movie and the makers are telling a story. When judging a movie based on fact, one of the best questions a reviewer should ask is this: Would this still be a good movie if it were entirely fictional? If you can’t make it work, you should probably be making a documentary. (Or at the very least you should have one character ask another, “Why are they doing this?” and then the other can say, “I don’t know.”)

Case in point, one of the best scenes in the movie is when Scooter Libby, aide to the Vice President, visits the Central Intelligence Agency and interviews one-by-one the CIA agents working on nonproliferation about some aluminum tubes. One CIA agent believes that they were being used to build nuclear fuel centrifuges. All of the other CIA agents have doubts because these tubes are the wrong size, type, and haven’t been used in any nuclear fuel reactor since 1952. But of course, they aren’t certain and they shouldn’t be. It’s not like the CIA has omniscient intelligence. Libby brings up the fact that in the First Gulf War Saddam Hussein actually was working on weapons of mass destruction, including nuclear bombs, and the CIA knew absolutely nothing about it. (For a comprehensive list of other things the CIA didn’t know or got wrong, go and read the book Legacy of Ashes.)  What Libby wants is the one agent who thinks the tubes are real evidence. As long as nobody else in the agency can tell him with 100% certainty that Hussein isn’t up to anything, he doesn’t care what he or she says. (95% isn’t good enough). Remember that line from ‘In the Loop,’ “In the land of ignorance, the man with one fact is king.”

Did that scene actually happen exactly as scripted and shot? I haven’t the slightest clue. But it is one of the best scenes because it explained the motivation of the antagonists in the story. That never happens again. We never get to know why the administration put the words in the speech or why they thought outing Valerie was a good idea. In the second half of the movie, we are shown quite a lot of talking heads on cable news bad-mouthing the Wilsons. But who are those people? Why are they saying those things? Did the administration tell them to do it? How does that work? It really isn’t enough to simply say that a smear is going on. What are the mechanics of a smear? Better yet, how do you tell if it is working? Who won this battle? What is the end result of a bunch of pundits yelling at each other on TV? The marriage survived, Libby was convicted, and a movie made. Are Joe and Valerie victors? Better yet, should we care? Because after all, isn’t the real issue WMD’s? My favorite scene in the movie takes place at a dinner party while Valerie is still a CIA operative currently working on the aluminum tubes thing. The other people at the table start up a really ignorant discussion about them, repeating all the stupid things they heard on TV. And there is Valerie sitting silently unable to discuss them in any way. Why? Because it would blow her cover to let on that she knows more than anybody at the table. Does it ever seem to you like the loudest most morally certain people around rarely know what they’re talking about?   

The movie ends with what is unfortunately becoming a movie cliché. The old “call to action.” Joe Wilson gives a speech to a classroom and implores the young people to go out there, become involved, and “do something about it.” I have passively heard this before and usually nodded my head but I will finally admit that I don’t really know what he means. Does he want me to vote Democrat or what? Should I become the annoying person at the dinner party? Should I think for myself by reading books other people recommend? Should I stop watching “Real Housewives” and get a life (i.e. do anything else)? Only one of these questions can I answer with real certainty. I prefer the way the documentary “The Cove” went about its call to action: Simply send a text message to sign a petition. Now that’s something I can do.

One more complaint: Doug Liman’s directing. He uses a hand-held camera for almost all of the shots. Bad decision. A hand-held camera tends to be shaky, unclear, and consistently out of focus in long shots. This can be annoying and distracting. There are times when a hand-held camera is called for. A documentary type film like, “JFK,” is a masterful example of that. The shaky camera in that movie works because the story itself is mysterious and unclear. A shaky camera works best as an admission from the director that the audience shouldn’t know exactly what is happening. The shakier the cam: the more uncertain the events. (This is also the reason why the History Channel uses blurred shaky cameras as well. They don’t know exactly what went on.) In this movie, Liman seems to be making the mistake that a shaky cam actually makes the movie feel more realistic and thus convincing. It doesn’t. It does the opposite. When a director wants to persuade the audience of his version of the facts, he should keep the damn camera still. Quite frankly, it also happens to be the professional thing to do. One of the first things they teach you in Broadcasting 101 is how to use a tri-pod. Come on people, this isn’t rocket science.





Sunday, October 24, 2010

Milk (5/5 Stars) 12/07/08

The last movie I saw Sean Penn in was "All the Kings Men." It was a flat out terrible and boring movie about a populist politician that gains power in a rough place only to be assassinated at the end. Supposedly it was based on the career of the real life politician Huey Long. That was early 2006. Sean Penn hasn't been in a movie since. Now he's in Milk, a movie about a populist politician that gains power in a rough place only to be assassinated at the end. It's based on the career of real life politician Harvey Milk. The main difference is that this movie isn't one of the worst of the year, it is one of the best. 
I had an awesome time at this movie. More than anything it made me want to go out and become a city supervisor. Not to be involved in the gay rights crusade, but simply to get involved in politics at a local level. That's where the action takes place you know, whether its quelling riots or simply getting the dog shit off the ground. The triumph of this movie is that it transcends a stigma of simply being pro-gay and tells, I think, a universal story of a community forming together and asserting themselves in the political process. It's a great movie about democracy and a savvy politician who used the system to help better the lives of his constituents. 
Sean Penn is getting huge buzz for his performance and he deserves it. He is virtually unrecognizable in this film. When I think of Sean Penn I think of the murderer in 'Dead Man Walking' or the gangster in 'Mystic River.' I would never have thought that he would be perfectly cast as a flamboyantly gay politician. He is so good in this movie that half way through I forgot about how good he was and just looked at the character as Harvey Milk. Sean Penn has a stamp on this guy. Just like Mozart, Elizabeth I, and Marie Antoinette, Harvey Milk is no longer public domain. He is owned by Sean Penn. This is one of the best performances of the year.
Shadowed by Penn is a bevy of other great performances. The two most notable are Emile Hirsch as Cleve Jones, one of Milk's subordinates. and a stunning turn for Josh Brolin, as the Conservative Catholic Dan White, one of Milk's fellow city supervisors and his eventual assassin. Brolin's performance is on the heels of two other notable ones in 'W.' and 'No Country for Old Men.' That makes a hat trick of good roles. He's been having quite the year and a half. In this one he thankfully gives us a better excuse for White's behavior than eating too many twinkies. Its an empathetic portrait of a man who finds himself caught in a dramatically changing society. And according to his upbringing the change is driven by degenerates and amorality. No wonder he has frustration when he fails delivering his platform and sees Harvey gain success on his. We see his world slipping away. After five years in prison we are told that Dan White committed suicide. Watching this movie you can understand why.
Overall this movie is sensational, inspirational, and smart. It was written by Dustin Lance Black and directed by Gus Van Sant. This is his first movie since 'Good Will Hunting' that may break out of indie land and into mainstream theaters...maybe. The subject matter might put a lot of people off. (It could win over a bunch of people I think if they didn't leave at the first love scene and saw the entire movie.) I expect to see Oscar Nominations from this movie. The lock is for Sean Penn for best actor. But other ones like Best Original Screenplay are a good bet. And I think Josh Brolin did a good enough job to warrant mention but Best Supporting Actor is so crowded every year that it is unlikely. 
I've come to notice that any movie taking place in the 1970s has this grainy look to the cinematography. Sort of like movies that take place in the 50s being in black and white. What's up with that.

Into the Wild 10/26/07

Into the Wild ventures to places that no other movies dare to go. Frank discussions about life, love, truth, honesty, independence, and beauty. It embraces these subjects and takes no prisoners. What a relief it is to find a film that will go so deep. Truly we laugh sometimes, we find the sight of Alexander Supertramp dragging his kayak through the Grand Canyon absurd. We giggle at the scraggly scruffy man walking the streets of Los Angelos. But underneath it is clear that he knows something that we don't and that there is something inside of him that allows him to do things we would never do, or are sure we cannot. This is one of the years best films.

This was adapted from a very good book by John Krakauer, who also wrote Into Thin Air. The book is a short easy read and it is told in a very uncinematic way. It is a testament to the filmmakers how they made the film work, and how every expansion and addition to the story was correct and appropriate. I love especially the swimming in the ocean, the conversations with Wayne (Vince Vaughn), and the love story (break my heart that God=love place they found and I'm sure actually exists.)
One scene made the movie for me. Alexander Supertramp (Christopher McCandless played by Emile Hirsch in a fantastic peformance) is kayaking down the Grand Canyon when he meets a random Scandinavian couple. They offer him hot dogs and talk excited German. Most people might think this is ridiculous but anyone who has been travelling will not. I travelled the world once upon a time, and I have had such encounters. Whether its a Brit in Chile, Canadians in Greece, an American professor in Krakow, a young married couple on a night train to Copenhagen, A Brazilian in Vienna. I once got lost in Italy, slept on a deserted walkway, and ended up talking to a drunk Spaniard named Lucas for a half hour at 1am. Good times. When watching this movie, I realized a certain nostalgia creep in. The movie felt like all those times I hiked alone in woods or up mountains, those endless walks in deserted cities. Pompeii, Kilimanjaro, Grand Canyon, Tuscany, Jungfraujoch, windmills in Amsterdam in a rain storm. The exhiliration one feels when witnessing a sight that is truly awesome. It is true that this happens only when one is alone. All the senses are heightened and everything is more intense and exciting. This movie knows that feeling inside and out. At two and a half hours it is short.
If anything this movie will get some recognition for Cinematography. There are so many incredible shots in this picture. birds in a sunset, alaskan mountains, the grand canyon, everything. For every hiker, biker, or people who like walking outside once in a while, I wholeheartedly recommend this movie. 

All the King's Men 01/09/07

Boy they really screwed up with this one. I've never seen a two and a half hour movie that really should have been longer. It seemed to me that they got scared people would be bored so they went out and took thirty minutes out of the movie. Unfortunately what they took out were all the moments that would make anyone care about the movie. Moments that explained who Willie Stark was, who he was fighting against, why we care about the girl, why we care about the guy. What exactly was corrupt about the governnor, why does Law care whether Winslett slept with Penn or not. Who the hell is the Ruffalo character. There's no backstory on this story. There isn't even a bad guy or antagonist. It's as if the director assumed we had read the book and only wanted to see the good scenes. This movie is like a puzzle with half the pieces missing. It should have been good. It was great on paper, but it isn't a complete movie and at two and a half hours that's pretty shameful.

By the way, this movie claimed to be about the Sean Penn character Willie Stark. It isn't. It's about a sad sack reporter who's name I can't remember played by Jude Law. He doesn't like Willie because Willie once went to a strip club. My God the horror. This movie probably made sense to anyone who thought Clinton really deserved to be impeached. It didn't make much sense to me.