Search This Blog

Showing posts with label christopher plummer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label christopher plummer. Show all posts

Sunday, January 26, 2020

Knives Out (5/5 Stars)



The Trope (aka Movie Cliché) abounds for a practical reason. They represent to the unimaginative a kind of shortcut in the creative process. Instead of going through the rigamorale of producing from scratch a totally original plot, they reuse tried and tested plot devices gleaned from genre and tradition. Like jokes told more than once, these tropes lose some of their effect each time they are employed, but this should not cover up their inherent truth: They are used so often because they work.

Perhaps the most used plot is the murder mystery. Agatha Christie at one point would churn these stories out annually making her the most best-selling author behind The Bible and William Shakespeare. Someone gets killed: Big Deal. The killer is still out there: Present Danger! Who is it? Suspense! The most used trope within the murder mystery plot is the locked room. That is, all the characters are in the same locked room with the dead body. We don’t know who the killer is but they must be someone in the room.

This story has been told many times over. As stated before, such retelling lowers the effectiveness of the trope. That is unless the writer reemploys creativity to the trope, subverting the audience’s already held expectations. In this way, the plot’s dull edged are resharpened and, once again employ their original effectiveness. Such is “Knives Out” an ingenious locked room murder mystery written and directed by Rian Johnson (Brick, Looper)

The setting is an old mansion isolated in the New England woods. Therein Harlan Thrombey (Christopher Plummer), best-selling author of murder mysteries, is holding his 85th birthday party. All his family is in attendance, a colorful privileged lot of bigoted conservatives and insufferable liberals. Harlan does many things that night to give a colorable argument for each of his family members to seek his death. And then Harlan commits suicide by slitting his own throat. The police are pretty sure it’s a suicide but then the great private detective Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig) shows up, hired by an unknown someone who suspects foul play.

Benoit Blanc is himself a mystery. He is played by an Englishman (James Bond no less), has a decidedly French name, and employs a southern accent. This is not explained. Without giving too much away, and I can’t because what I am about to reveal happens in the first twenty minutes, the story is not necessarily a whodunit, but more of a how did a particular character didn’t do it?

We are shown in the first twenty minutes that Harlan’s in-house nurse Marta Cabrera (Ana de Armas) mixes up his medication, giving him an overdose of morphine. In order to spare her a criminal conviction, Harlan instructs her how to escape the house without attracting suspicion and then kills himself. But is that all to this story? And who hired Benoit Blanc to investigate? And why?

The family of Harlan Drysdale is a cabinet of unique caricatures and good casting. The more important ones are: Linda Drysdale, daughter of Harlan (Jamie Lee Curtis), her husband Richard Drysdale (Don Johnson), and their playboy son Ransom Drysdale (Chris Evans); Walt Thrombey, son of Harlan (Michael Shannon); Joni Thrombey (Toni Collete), daughter-in-law of Harlan. It is to the credit of Rian Johnson, that they are not all terrible people. They have their faults, and some are worse than others. Others, like Walt Thrombey, are not so bad, well, most of the time. In this way, the writer throws the audience leads and red herrings and makes us thinks very hard about how much we trust everyone.

There is one character that Rian Johnson wants us to trust completely and that is the in-house nurse Marta Cabrera. Marta has a medical disorder that causes her to vomit every time she tells a lie. But she is also the one who gave Harlan a fatal dose of morphine and last saw him before he died. How did she not do it? Well, watch the movie and see if you can figure it out before the cliché everyone-in-the same room as the great detective makes his speech scene. The reveal is highly effective.

Saturday, January 7, 2012

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (3/5 Stars)




Rooney Mara does not look like Lisbeth Salander. Lisbeth is small, skinny, and sharp. Rooney is of average height, healthy, and round all over. She lost weight for this role and somehow managed to pinch in her cheeks a little but it is not enough. Rooney is a doe-eyed babyface. Lisbeth is not. There is no getting around it.

It is hard to say why this matters so much. For some reason I am thinking of something obscure that I saw in the special features of a completely different movie. It was in “Three Kings” a movie about the first Iraq War. One of the Iraqis (Said Taghmaoui, I just looked up his name on IMDb) that played a bad guy was speaking of meeting the actor Ice Cube for the first time and how he could tell that he came from a rough neighborhood (Compton to be exact). He said he could tell by the eyes. People who have grown up in a rough neighborhood have it ingrained around their eyes. He knew that because he grew up in a rough neighborhood in Iraq. And then he said Ice Cube knew that simply by looking at him as well. Ever since I heard that I became much more interested in eyes. Does being witness to rough things over a period of time really leave its mark on the eyes? I don’t know honestly, but as a person who watches many movies I will say that there is something about the eyes that can create a certain seriousness or desperation in a character, which incidentally can convey a history of seeing rough things. Good examples are Viggo Mortenson in “Eastern Promises,” and Charlize Theron in “Monster.” And perhaps the best example is Noomi Rapace’s take on Lisbeth Salander in the original Swedish version of “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.” Those eyes were piercing. Rooney Mara’s are not. The role has been miscast. Rooney would make more sense as a Disney princess.

This is a pity because this movie is technically better than the Swedish version. We have none other than David Fincher, one of the best American directors, at the helm here. Fincher has excelled at serial killers (Seven) and has excelled at complex subjects (The Social Network), sometimes both at the same time (Zodiac). The convoluted 40-year-old murder mystery that is the centerpiece of “The Girl with the Dragon Tatoo,” is a ready made plot for the likes of Fincher. If you have a story that requires a journalist to do a realistic investigation (i.e. painstakingly go over evidence, hit the books at the library), Fincher is the guy who can make it interesting, lend it humor, and give it momentum. Here the disgraced journalist Michael Blomvist (played by Daniel Craig) is hired to solve a family mystery that involves a close-knit family with Nazi connections. The mystery is intricate to the highest degree but Fincher’s clear direction shines through it. In fact, for the first half of the movie where the mystery plotline runs parallel and separate to the introduction of Lisbeth Salander, it is the more interesting plot to watch unfold. In the Swedish version it was the other way around. Now if only we could insert Noomi Rapace into the American version.

Not that all of Fincher’s choices seem to be entirely correct. There was something wrong with this movie that was hard to put my finger on while I was watching it. So I went back and rewatched several scenes from the original version. The plot is exactly the same of course. What is different may be as little as tweaked dialogue, different camera angles, or simply physical gestures. But it is unmistakable how the movies have different impacts precisely where it is most important: how it regards Lisbeth Salander. This is touchy subject because there are two scenes of sexual assault in the story, one being a rape. Now I suppose I could be like the MPAA and basically judge the difference between the two versions by how many seconds of nakedness were shown in each. (There is far more in the American version. It actually surprised me upon a second viewing how little is actually shown in the Swedish version. Only about a half-second. The rest is all inferred. Both distort and mute the screaming after awhile, a rather merciful thing to do for an audience.) But the more important differences take place before and after the rape.  The rapist is Lisbeth’s legal guardian, newly appointed after her old guardian had a stroke. The sexual assaults start as a form of extortion. Lisbeth won’t have access to her own money until complying. Now, in the Swedish version it only takes one meeting before the first sexual assault. In the American version, it takes a back-story and two meetings to get around to it. It seems as though the American version is trying to ease us into the sexual assault. A pointless exercise in futility it would seem to me. The biggest difference though is that the American version also adds scenes right after the assaults where Lisbeth dresses herself, goes into the next room where the rapist is waiting to give her check, takes it and leaves. The Swedish version simply cut from the assault to Lisbeth washing out her mouth and painfully walking home respectively. What is the point of these extra scenes? At my least cynical moment I will assume that the makers were attempting to make the rapist look pathetic (in the movie he seems a bit frightened and apologetic after the assault). But even so, who gives a shit? What does it matter how the rapist feels about what he has done? It is enough that the actions exist as they do in the world. Time to move onto the next scene. 

There are some styles and genres of movies where it is okay to objectify women (or rather people in general). I wrote about this in some length when I defended “Sucker Punch,” a comic book movie that came out earlier this year. But when the original title of the book the movie is from is called, “Men who Hate Women,” I think we have entered territory where any objectification at all should be barred entirely. Take a look at the movie poster above, which shows a topless Lisbeth Salandar. Is it really appropriate for the marketers of a movie about one of the most powerful symbols of sexual violence to sell their movie with the promise of sex? (You may also ask what exactly the poster means by “Evil shall with evil be expelled.” Are they insinuating that Blomvist and Salandar are evil or using evil? How so?) The Swedish version at least seemed to understand that sexual abuse is not such an easy thing to get over. The way Noomi Rapace played the character in the consensual sex scenes, and there a couple of those, was for lack of a better word, tragic. She could go through the motions but was incapable of intimacy. That makes sense considering the character’s history. The way Rooney Mara interacts with Daniel Craig in the American version would work much better in a James Bond flick. Rooney Mara would not make a bad Bond girl.

For the record, I still don’t fully understand how the epilogue heist worked in either version of this movie. Perhaps if I read the book.


Sunday, October 24, 2010

The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (4/5 Stars) February 4, 2010

Gilliam Goes CGI

There are perhaps only two American directors I can think of that employ visual styles that unapologetically engross whatever story is being told. The first and certainly more prolific is Tim Burton. The second and unfortunately consistently out-of-work director is Terry Gilliam. 100 years ago they would surely have been world famous painters or something. They are perfect example of my theory that all the best artists have left the still-life painting world and gone into movies. (I also happen to believe all the best poets have become musicians or screenwriters. (Sculptors have become bodybuilders, ha ha.)) I think Gilliam’s style can best be described as “Salvador Dali visits a junkyard.” Still that’s doesn’t do it justice. If anything, Dali is a very unaccomplished Gilliam who does art in really static and boring ways (and doesn’t use as much trash.) It’s not Dali’s fault he’s so inferior though. He just didn’t have the technology. Movies and CGI special effects in general allow artists such as Gilliam to go places a guy like Dali never could. This movie is also a perfect argument for my idea to clean out all the crap-art in the MOMA and just hang still frames from great movies for a change. 

The story in this movie is kind of convoluted. Doctor Parnassus, played by Christopher Plummer, made a bet with Mr. Nick, aka the devil played by Tom Waits, that he could use his imagination to capture more souls (of apparently innocent passersbys) than the devil could. Doctor Parnassus won the bet and Mr. Nick granted him eternal life. Unfortunately, as all bets with the devil turn out, it was a blessing in disguise. Doctor Parnassus ages, he just never dies. 1000 years later he’s on the street accompanied only by his dwarf friend, played by Verne Troyer, begging for change. At this point a beautiful woman, played by the supermodel Lily Cole, walks by and Parnassus falls in love. Mr. Nick, always liking a deal, agrees to grant Parnassus his youth again so he can woo her in exchange for his first-born daughter at the age of 16 (again Lily Cole). Fast forward another 100 years (the movie doesn’t go chronologically by the way) to the beginning of the movie when Parnassus is at the centerpiece of some freak travelling show that hangs outside modern bars near freeway underpasses. He has an imaginarium that does crazy shit. His fellow travelling band members find a mysterious stranger named Tony, played by Heath Ledger, hanged somehow from the underside of a bridge. He’s got this lucky fife and has a plan to…

Well, whatever. Suffice to say that the story doesn’t really matter. Or should I say the story matters as much as the story in one of your dreams matter. It seems pretty vivid and real when you’re in it. Places, people, and things transform and transition into different places, people, and things quite seamlessly. But once you awake you can’t really remember what logic wound the whole thing together. Every thing blurs like a stream of consciousness. But I want to make the point that I wasn’t entirely bothered by this. I may not have understood what was going on some of the time but there was always incredible dazzling visual somethings to behold. This is one of those movies you can play muted on your TV during a party. I bet it would be a great conversation piece. (Is this supposed to be an acid trip? What the hell is going on??)

Stuff needs to be said about the imaginarium. How it works is this: A person walks into it and gets transported into a fantasyland created by the mind of Doctor Parnassus. This place will usually be tailored to the traveler inside. Like say a kid has a candy-land fantasy imagined for him. A wealthy woman has a fantasy filled with gigantic pearl necklaces, gold coins, and high heels. Etc. etc. Every single trip inside the magic mirror is something different and something special. At the end of the trip the traveler is presented with a choice between choosing the imagination of Mr. Nick (like say a shady bar or seedy inn) or of Dr. Parnassus (steep staircase to heaven, a bunch of transvestite cops dancing a show tune.) Whoever wins gets the traveler’s soul. Then there’s how Gilliam dealt with Heath Ledger’s death halfway through shooting the picture. All the principal on-set shooting had already been finished so all there was left was imaginarium scenes. Well, instead of just throwing in the towel because one of the major actors passed away, Gilliam just invented the idea that Tony’s looks are morphed by whatever imagination is being serviced in the imaginarium at that time. So each of Tony’s trip into the imaginarium produces a different movie star cameo: Johnny Depp, Colin Farrel, and Jude Law respectively (wow two good Jude Law movies in a week. I’ve stepped into the twilight zone). This works splendidly mostly because no logic is required in an imaginarium. The best thing about the imaginarium scenes though is that they are in CGI. What this does is offset Gilliam’s notorious penchant for real life grunge. What I’ve noticed while watching Gilliam’s many movies is how ugly (though very imaginative) the art direction is. (Ex. 12 Monkeys, Time Bandits, Monty Python). Fortunately it’s practically impossible to do something as realistic as dirty grungy trashy trash with CGI. So Gilliam was forced to design some beautiful art for a change. This movie proves he can.

The actors casted in this movie are like Gilliam works of art in themselves. Google Lily Cole, Verne Troyer (aka Mini-me from Austin Powers) and Christopher Plummer and see what I mean. All of them fit neatly in ancient surrealistic landscapes. Perhaps the best character though is Mr. Nick played by the rockstar Tom Waits. You should look that guy up on Pandora. He’s got a gravelly voice that bests Bob Dylan. The devil has never sounded so devilish. We had an especially poor collection of Supporting Actors in this year’s Oscar Race. Tom Waits was unfairly overlooked. Last but not least is Heath Ledger. His performance was the hardest to wrap my head around. If it had all been done by Ledger, it may have made more sense. But this is something I’m not about to hassle a dead man about. He did fine and the Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus is a pretty good movie to go out on. It at least speaks to his very ambitious taste for interesting roles in fearless movies. He will be missed. Rest in Peace.

UP (4/5 Stars) June 8, 2009

UP is the latest film from Pixar, that collossas of animation studios that have spawned such great works of art as Toy Story, Monsters Inc., Finding Nemo, Ratatouille, and Wall-e. Pixar’s reputation is second to none. They are the most consistent creator of not just great-animated features great movies in general. And to say one of their movies lives up to the Pixar reputation doesn’t merely infer that the movie is good. It infers that the movie is great. That it contains warmth, humor, creativity, a wealth of imagination, images that will dazzle the eyes, and a story that will delight audiences both young and old. UP, a story of adventure about an elderly man and his floating house lives up to Pixar’s reputation.
UP starts with a love story between two young adventurers, Carl and Ellie. Their dream is to fly to South America and explore the rain forest. They grow up and get married. Ellie is a zookeeper and Carl is a balloon salesman. They save up for the trip but life gets in the way and eventually Ellie gets cancer and passes away. All of this is played without dialogue and accompanied by one of the happiest/saddest melody I’ve heard in a movie in some time. At 78 Carl has turned into an old grump threatened by developers and being coerced into a nursing home. What does he do? He attaches a mountain of balloons onto his home and takes off in his flying house toward the jungles of South America. An over-enthusiastic boy scout who was attempting to earn his merit badge for assisting the elderly unexpectedly joins him. Together they have adventures in the brightly colored rain forests of South America encountering a rare bird and a truly evil long forgotten explorer who lives in his very own museum/blimp catered to by his army of masterly trained talking dogs. Adventures ensue that include much slapstick comedy, sight gags, and elderly combat that surpasses anything seen in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, the last film about old people adventuring in South America. Plenty of the daredevil antics take place in very high places. People afraid of heights should beware. Up is definitely up there for most of the time. 
The only drawback this had was the 3-D aspect of it. Now this is the best 3-D movie I have ever seen, but that in it is not saying much. Traditionally 3-D doesn’t so much help in telling a story as it directly provokes the audience. In this movie, Pixar has done a lot of good work in all the close shots, adding some impressive depth and detail to the picture. But in faraway shots, the 3-D looks distorted and blurry (especially with the 3-D pigeons and clouds). Quite frankly, it distracts from the picture. 3-D is a good gag in Disneyland amusement rides but it doesn’t help when one is trying to suspend one’s reality. 3-D has a tendency to take the viewer out of the picture and point out to the viewer that he is not in South America but in a movie theater wearing silly glasses. Another thing that 3-D does is unintentionally make the screen darker. The sunglasses that need to be worn diminish some of the brightness that is associated with animation. The rainforest in UP are not as stimulating as they should be. Having said all of this, I recommend that people see UP on the biggest screen possible without 3-D. I bet the movie will be brighter, more involving, and, dare I say, better.
UP concludes a trio of films by Pixar (started by Ratatouille and Wall-e) that are based on almost unmarketable ideas (rats that cook, robots that love, and now old adventurers). Their next films are said to be Toy Story 3 and Cars 2. Perhaps we will look back on these three years and proclaim it as Pixar’s golden age, the time when they were so on the top of their game that they could turn weird quirky ideas into not just great insightful animation but also crowd-pleasing blockbusters. Could it get any better than this? It’s hard to believe, but with Pixar anything seems possible.

Syriana 12/11/05

This movie was confusing and half the time I didn't know what was going on. Only at about halfway or whatever through the movie did I get some inkling of something. I wish I had gotten more, I wish this because the subject is so interesting. Wouldn't we all want to know something more about the oil business. But this movie never stops to explain. It shows lots of places, lots of people, lots of situations. There's a story about a corporation merger, a dynastic struggle in an Arab nation, the training of a muslim jihadist, a betrayed CIA agent. I wish for once, they would pause the constant setting switches and have two people sit down and have a long talk about what's going on. But again, this never happens. Instead the characters make small talk, nods, and whispers. And that's the reasons why the movie fails. A movie may have all the materials for success, but if the audience doesn't understand what's going and why, they won't become emotionally involved. At some points in the story, I'm sure what was happening was important, but I didn't know why. I was shut out of the story, and if that's what the writer/director has in mind, then I'm not too impressed. (A shame really, it looked like a good movie)