Search This Blog

Thursday, April 16, 2015

OSCARS 2015



Usually I can find some type of narrative for a year in movies but 2014 proved elusive. I saw some good ones, a few great ones, but not a single one that stood out as the very best of the year. But here are a few thoughts: 

- The big action superhero blockbuster is on some level entering a level of supercompetence. I did not see one that was particularly bad this year. 
- I was inspired not only by the directiorial debut of a very young director Damien Chazelle (Whiplash) but also a very old one, Clint Eastwood, who just made one of his best movies in his mid-80s (American Sniper). Both movies were pleasant surprises to me.
- 'Birdman' though not special to me in a personal sense expanded my idea of how a movie can accomplish certain things. The long shots called attention to the actors and allowed the acting to be bigger and more theatrical. Here they expanded the role of the actors sometimes to theatrical levels. What a revelation!
- Go Texas. Houston born Wes Anderson, Austin native son Richard Linklater, and the movie 'American Sniper' were all great movies with that connection. You can make it a TexMex year if you include Alejandro Innaritu. On to the awards.

There were a certain categories that I did not watch anything in. One was the short films which is not unusual. The other was the foreign language category which is unusual. It just did not happen this year. I don't know why. 

Then there a couple categories in which I only saw one film that applies. So they win automatically. Thankfully they were deserving anyway.


Best Animated Feature Film
 The Lego Movie 

I was struck by how the movie seemed to have been written by a ten-year-old, which was very appropriate and highly satisfying. Also Will Ferrell had a touching cameo at the end that summed up all that Lego stands for. This was the best commercial I saw all year.




Best Documentary
CitizenFour

Not a great documentary in art and craft but its newsworthiness makes it a very important document of our time and place.






Best Supporting Actor:
Kim Bodnia – Rosewater
Josh Brolin – Inherent Vice
Ethan Hawke – Boyhood
Mark Ruffalo – Foxcatcher
J.K. Simmons – Whiplash

Always a tough category but Josh Brolin's turn as a SAG detective with a flattop haircut of Flinstone proportions in Inherit Vice was the most memorable fictional character I saw all year. 






Best Supporting Actress:
Patricia Arquette – Boyhood
Laura Dern - Wild
Eva Green – Sin City: A Dame to Kill For
Jennifer Lawrence - X-Men: Days of Future Past
Emma Stone – Birdman

Always a very shallow category. Patricia Arquette gets it for her 12 year performance in 'Boyhood. Nobody else was close. The fact that Meryl Streep was nominated again shows that (and a very apparent lack of imagination in the Academy). 






Best Use of a Song:
“I Love You All” – Frank
“Come and Get Your Love” – Guardians of the Galaxy
 “Your Fault” – Into the Woods
“Everything is Awesome” – The Lego Movie
“Caravan” – Whiplash

I thought a lot about switching up Frank and Whiplash for this one but ultimately decided that I would give the Film Editing prize to Whiplash for its ending scene whereas the song that ends 'Frank' is not only original but the first original song in forever that actually deserved an Oscar. For some reason it was not nominated for an Oscar. That was the biggest surprise for me of the year in this pathetically shallow category.





Best Original Music Score:
Birdman
The Grand Budapest Hotel
The Imitation Game
Interstellar

Really the only Original Music Score that really stood out to me was the one from "The Grand Budapest Hotel." I am thinking of making this category just "Best Soundtrack" in the future. I would have at least nominated 'Chef' if that were the case. 





Best Sound Editing and Mixing

American Sniper
Birdman
Edge of Tomorrow
Interstellar
Whiplash

It seems like I say this every year but this is a category that is very hard for me to judge while watching the movie. Given that I had the same list of movies for Editing and Mixing and because a friend of mine basically told me that the people who do editing generally do the mixing as well, I combined the categories. Why American Sniper? Well, basically because I actually noticed the Sound Editing in that movie, particularly when Chris Kyle was back in the States and getting alerted by phantom sounds of warfare. It was effective.






Best Film Editing:
American Sniper
Foxcatcher
The Grand Budapest Hotel
Whiplash
Wild

The editing in Whiplash is truly extraordinary. It transforms the energy of a low budget first feature into the work of an accomplished director with many more millions of dollars to spend. This is cut like an action film and feels that way with nothing but jazz going on. 





Best Makeup:
Foxcatcher
Guardians of the Galaxy
The Grand Budapest Hotel

I generally don't go wild over makeup for Holy Mackeral this movie had Great Makeup. I especially liked blue robot woman.






Best Costume Design:
The Grand Budapest Hotel
Guardians of the Galaxy
Inherent Vice

Yes, that Summer Blockbuster had the most awesome costumes ever too. Take a look at what Benecio Del Toro was wearing in that one scene. And yellow prison suits: Awesome. 






Best Production Design:
The Grand Budapest Hotel
Interstellar
Into the Woods
A Most Violent Year
The Zero Theorem

Truly nothing else came close to the achievement of vision that is "The Grand Budapest Hotel." You could say that the movie was named after the production design.






Best Visual Effects:
Edge of Tomorrow
Guardians of the Galaxy
Interstellar
X-Men: Days of Future Past
The Zero Theroem

There is visual effects and then there is Visual Effects that you need astrophysicists to consult with to make right. This one is for the Black Hole. 






Best Cinematography:
Birdman
The Grand Budapest Hotel
Interstellar
A Most Violent Year
Nightcrawler

Lubezski wins his second Oscar in a row and rightly deserves both. He is the master of the long shot and teaches a master class here in how they should be done and more importantly why they should be done. 






Best Original Screenplay:
Wes Anderson, Hugo Guinness - The Grand Budapest Hotel
Jon Favreau - Chef
Justin Lader - The One I Love
Alejandro Innaritu, Nicolas Giacobone, Alexander Dinares Jr., Armando Bo - Birdman
J.C. Chandor - A Most Violent Year

I don't think I have seen a movie with so many great vocabulary words interspersed effortlessly thoughout the entire picture. When Jeff Goldblum is perfectly cast it is because you got some delicious words for him to chew on. 







Best Adapted Screenplay:
Jason Hall - American Sniper
Paul Thomas Anderson - Inherent Vice
Jon Stewart - Rosewater
Nick Hornby - Wild
Simon Kinberg - X-Men: Days of Future Past

Paul Thomas Anderson gets this for the ingenious way he crammed so many visual jokes into a such a complex and convoluted storyline. It is a feat to behold. 






Best Actress:
Elisabeth Moss – The One I Love
Kristin Wiig – The Skeleton Twins
Julianne Moore - Still Alice
Reese Witherspoon – Wild
Jessica Chastain – A Most Violent Year

This was not a great year for the Best Actress category. It could be easily said that Julianne Moore won it because she is a great actress who had not won the award yet and you know who else would you give it to this year. Besides her performance in "Still Alice" probably reminded the voters of a performance she had twenty years ago that probably was good enough to this year. That movie was "Safe" and it too was about a degenerative disease. See that movie. 






Best Actor:
Steve Carell – Foxcatcher
Bradley Cooper – American Sniper
Michael Fassbender – Frank
Michael Keaton – Birdman
Channing Tatum – Foxcatcher

Three of these nominees (Carell, Cooper, and Keaton) had career milestones this year. I'm giving this to Carell because his role is the most against type and also because his movie 'Foxcatcher' arguably had the best acting in a movie this year. 






Best Director:
Wes Anderson – The Grand Budapest Hotel
Paul Thomas Anderson – Inherent Vice
Damien Chazelle – Whiplash
Alejandro Innaritu – Birdman
Richard Linklater – Boyhood

It just cannot be denied any longer. There is no other director like Wes Anderson and he just turned in his best work in an already very impressive two decade career. 

Best Picture:
American Sniper
Birdman
Boyhood
Chef
Foxcatcher
The Grand Budapest Hotel
Inherit Vice
A Most Violent Year
Whiplash
X-Men: Days of Future Past

The Grand Budapest Hotel was the first movie I saw in theaters in 2014 and although I felt it was unlikely that I would not see a better movie all year I also knew that it was entirely possible that I had just seen the best movie of the year. I loved this movie. It was a poem to civilization crafted with all sorts of love.


Sunday, March 29, 2015

CitizenFour (4/5 Stars)



They are watching you. Well maybe not watching right this moment. But in the future, if you ever became a person of interest for whatever reason, they could go back in their files and find everything you’ve done all the way up to this point. It has all been recorded and handed over to the government surveillance through secret court orders. This is no conspiracy theory. It is a fact of the times we live in. And we know this because of a hero, ex-NSA contractor Edward Snowden who provided journalists, Laura Poitras and Glenn Greenwald, in the summer of 2013 the internal classified documents of the NSA to prove it. 

“CitizenFour” recently won the Oscar for Best Documentary. This is not a particularly great documentary in terms of craft or creativity, but it is the most important in terms of sheer newsworthiness. That week in June when all the stories were leaked and Snowden came out as the whistleblower is going to be in history books. This movie shows the entire week from beginning to end all in a Hong Kong hotel room. Someone needs to put a plaque right next to door commemorating the event. I suspect it will become a cult tourist destination. It is on my list if I ever go back to Hong Kong.

To truly appreciate what Snowden did it is best to understand how he went about doing it. To do this I suggest watching Alex Gibney’s documentary “We Steal Secrets: The Story of Wikileaks,” which concerns the whistleblowing of Julian Assange and Bradley Manning. Those two were rank amateurs way over their heads compared to the competence and eloquence of Greenwald, Poitras, and Snowden. Unlike the Wikileaks whistleblowing which just flopped a bunch of sensitive material on the internet for all to see, Snowden took special care to make sure the documents he was revealing put nobody from the intelligence community in physical danger. It was an overview of programs not an outing of personnel. Secondly, Snowden took responsibility in a heroic way. He kept his girlfriend, family, and co-workers out of his plans. He coordinated with journalists with good reputations. And he was determined to not be anonymous like Bradley Manning. The documents were leaked in Glen Greenwald’s and Laura Poitra’s newspapers throughout the week in deliberate sequencing and then Snowden was revealed at the end. In this way the story was always about the secret surveillance, the news cycle gave utmost attention to each reveal, and just when the story was about to switch over to who was doing this and why, Snowden came out and made the mystery a moot point. It was a brilliant strategy and a true thrill to sit in that hotel room with them and watch very smart people plot the strategy for important historical things in real time. Edward Snowden comes off as good a person someone can come off as in this movie. Where he really shines is in his aptitude in discussing all the programs and the power and capabilities of the technology in them. He knows his stuff and he knows that he is tapping Leviathan on the shoulder and asking for a fight. But he has thought this through. His motives are pure. His actions are important. And the journalists he has allied with are the best in the business. Contrast that with the disturbed loose cannon that was Bradley Manning and the overconfident narcissism of Julian Assange and you have a master’s class on how to and how not to be a whistleblower. Did anyone say double feature partytime?

The subject of the NSA for anyone who has the experience of reading a Bamford book is especially taxing to the mind. It is a story of complex technology and large warehouses and confusing cryptology. It is almost impossible to stay awake during these stories without wanting to latch onto a personality. (This is generally the public’s large problem with this national security problem. One of Snowden’s main points is not in the government’s actions towards specific people [although 1.2 million people are identified as being on the ‘terrorist’ watchlist] but the capabilities that the government has set up. Imagine he says if the people in charge really wanted to do really bad things. They could very well do it quite easily. There is nowhere to hide and the checks and balances in the system are a complete joke. [The secret FISA court only denied less than 1% of all requests from the intelligence community for search warrants. That is what you call a rubberstamp.]) To that end Poitras does a rather keen thing in narrating the story in the first person when dealing with her experience with Snowden. The way she describes being put on a ‘watchlist’ for being a journalist who talked about these things is rather chilling. Unfortunately (and rather oddly) we never actually see Poitras during the documentary. Why she chose to narrate in the first person (putting herself into the story) without putting herself on the screen is an odd choice. She is missed.

Remember that Steven Spielberg movie, “Minority Report,” starring Tom Cruise. It was about a future police state that had achieved a zero murder rate by using precogs to predict murders and stop them before they happened. The movie took the stance that this type of surveillance and its effects was not worth the loss of privacy. Really? A zero murder rate? Not worth the loss of privacy. It was an odd position I thought to take. What I felt was really wrong about the future police state was that the people who were stopped from committing the crimes were still punished for them. They were warehoused in an enforced deep sleep that seemed to me to be even worse than solitary confinement. That, I felt, was the real problem. After all (and I speak to this as one who has studied city planning from a security viewpoint) surveillance really does work as a way to reduce crime. This does not necessarily mean that city streets need a police presence. (In fact, a strong police presence can actually make a street feel less safe.) But they do need “eyes on the street,” that is to say a safe street is one that is constantly populated by people in the neighborhood. A city that organizes itself to make sure that ordinary people are going about their business at all times of the day and night on that street makes a safe street. In this way I support surveillance to deter crime. The odd thing about NSA surveillance is that it is secret. How is secret surveillance a deterent to crime? It isn’t. What’s more, the way we punish criminals is also generally a secret. We have Supermax prisons in the middle of nowhere that incarcerate prisoners for very long periods of time in solitary confinement. You have to dig down deep in order to find anything about these places. That is not a deterent to crime either. Combine that with the erosion of the 4th Amendment in the War on Drugs, idiotic minimum sentences for low-level crimes, and three strikes laws. Now take what we just learned in Ferguson, Missouri, where it was found that the local police force (looking like the fucking army with assault rifles, riot gear, and tanks) was acting like a tax collector and you start seeing the State less as an agent of law and order and more of a co-conspirantant in a business model preying on people not protecting them.

For the longest time Americans have been dangerously complicit and complacent to these happeninings because the main victims are a marginalized group of people, poor blacks. It is time to put an end to this for everybody. The present civil rights violations are not confined to race. As Snowden points out, anybody who gains power has the ability to use this against anyone. Transparent surveillance is one thing. Perhaps it would be for the best if the Internet were a public space with less anonymity. But secret surveillance is another thing entirely. Combine that with a justice system weakened consistently by forever wars, we have the largest threat to American freedom today.




Thursday, March 5, 2015

Whiplash (4/5 Stars)





Good Job

I could not be more impressed by a second feature and a first real budget (still low budget but still a budget) movie. The writer is Damien Chazelle. He is my age (OMFG) and his movie is absolutely killer. It is the sort of thing that registers a new cinematic presence in the neighborhood of greatness in your mind. I am excited for future movies from this kid. Let me explain: It is not too unusual for a very young person to give a great performance or write a very good screenplay or even to direct a good movie (take Ryan Coogler’s “Fruitvale Station” from last year). It’s unusual but not unheard of unusual. But the standout great thing about “Whiplash” is not any of these things. It is the editing. And Editing like Cinematography is a technical old-man-who-knows-how-to-work-machines job. Those other jobs can lean on the crutch of great inspiration or raw talent. Editing is a craft. Editing requires discipline and experience. And the editing that one experiences in “Whiplash” is so intricate, precise, and correct that to see a 28-year-old lead a team that does it is extraordinary. We need to give this Damien Chazelle some serious money and let him do whatever the fuck he wants next time around. The kid’s got rhythm.

“Whiplash” is a low budget movie. It has a protagonist (Jazz Drummer protégé played by Miles Teller) an antagonist (his sadistic/inspiring teacher played by J.K. Simmons) and two supporting characters: his easy going father and a girlfriend. The movie takes place in a series of rooms and concert halls and some country roads. The plot concerns the protagonist’s search for greatness in jazz drumming, his attempts to impress a teacher who is ideologically opposed to ever being impressed, and his ultimate confrontation and jazz drum battle with him. Now there is that on paper but on the screen you are watching what feels like an action blockbuster. This is pulled off by a focused screenplay, two great performances by Teller and Simmons and as I mentioned before extraordinary editing.

Jazz Drumming? Who gives a shit right? I knew nothing about it before seeing this movie (except of course for the Buddy Rich tapes). Well the presentation of a thing makes a world of difference. I am reminded of watching Bob Fosse’s “All That Jazz” and being turned off by the philandering reckless play director until the movie proved through choreography that he was a genius. There’s nothing like great art to diminish the distasteful eccentricities of the artist. So it is in “Whiplash.”Miles Teller really wants to be one of the greatest jazz drummers ever like Buddy Rich or Charlie Parker. His teacher mercilessly abuses him (not unlike the drill instructor in “Full Metal Jacket.”) There is yelling, slapping, throwing chairs, and sadistic mind fucking going all around. Miles practices until his hands start bleeding. He blows off his father. He breaks up with his girlfriend in order to focus more on his music. Why would Miles Teller go through this? Well fuck it’s the music. It’s great. And it fills the scenes with gorgeous suspense and hideous beauty. And the camera direction and editing seamlessly intertwine the pieces into the overall experience. The movie makes it plausible that greatness in this medium is worth experiencing terrible shit.

By making it plausible the movie opens a real discussion of whether greatness is worth destroying yourself in general. Miles has two father figures. His dad, easy going and unconditional in his love, is not particularly great at anything and requires nothing from his son. Then there is his teacher who demands and demands and demands and demands and who articulates that the most harmful words in the human language are “Good Job.” Well, is J.K. Simmons a good teacher? I have an opinion on that. I do not necessarily believe that yelling, slapping, or throwing chairs is bad leadership. I do have a problem with the manipulation and the lying. At one point in the movie the teacher confronts a student who is on-pitch with the accusation that they are off-pitch. The teacher knows that the student is on pitch. He also must know that in his strict disciplitarian camp of a classroom that the student cannot talk back or correct the teacher. And yet his excuse for his behavior when the student is dismissed is “well, he wasn’t off pitch but should have known that he wasn’t and that is worse.” So what is the point of his behavior? It is a perfect Catch-22 for the student. They will either get excoriated for differing from the teacher or get excoriated for being off pitch. There is no point is the answer. It is stupid and the teacher is a coward to only yell louder when he is called out on it. So “Full Metal Jacket” guy: all good in my book. I like him. The teacher in this movie: not so much. One kind of yelling toughens up a pupil, the other fucks with their mind. And if the teacher is not there to mold the mind, if he insists like in this movie that the perfect pupil will ultimately disregard his teaching than what is the point of the teacher at all.

Or to put it another way: What is the point of teachers when it comes to Greatness. If it can’t be taught then perhaps the best teacher is but an intelligent obstacle.

Or did I just persuade myself the other way….

Thursday, February 26, 2015

American Sniper (5/5 Stars)




Early on in “American Sniper,” Chris Kyle (played by Bradley Cooper) sidles up to his future wife in a bar. She tells him to get lost. Why he asks? Because you are a Navy Seal she says, and Navy Seals are pushy, self-centered, egotistical, loud, etc. Chris takes most of this in a way that suggests he is in agreement with her assessment of how Nacy Seals are. He does however take issue with one adjective. “Self-centered,” he objects, “I would give my life for my country. How is that self-centered?”

“American Sniper” is an extraordinary character study. It shows the life of Chris Kyle who served four tours in the Iraq War and was credited with 160 confirmed kills as a sniper before coming home and being shot and killed by a fellow veteran with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. As far as war movies are concerned it belongs in that new brand of modern cinema that makes obsolete the line between a bullshit PG rated John Wayne version of war and a slow motion violin-playing Oliver Stone version of a war. It is more like the “The Hurt Locker,” another movie that showed real brutality of a battle side by side with its strange ability to seduce the fighter to keep coming back to it. Like the I.E.D. specialist in “The Hurt Locker,” Chris Kyle only owes one tour of duty but keeps volunteering for more. Once he is home with his loving wife and kids he can’t think of anything more important than going back to Iraq to finish the war.

Cinema in general is a liberal establishment and this type of behavior is unreal to most of the people in it. They look at Chris Kyle’s accomplishments (i.e. killing a record number of people) in a very unpopular war and recoil at the idea that anybody over there could be called a hero. I hope they see this movie because the fact that Chris Kyle was nicknamed “Legend” by his fellow soldiers has far less an insidious truth to it than they think. He was “Legend” because when he watched over the battlefield with his rifle, the men on the ground were never safer. (In one scene the soldiers relieving him at his post find him in position on his rifle but stinking of urine. He wouldn’t take his sight off the street for however long it would take to piss.) In other words, Kyle saved many lives of American soldiers and that is why he is considered a hero. Unfortunately those statistics are impossible to tally. Of course one could make the argument that the entire war was wrong in the first place so it does not matter that Kyle killed people to save people if nobody at all deserved to die. I think Chris Kyle had the best retort in his book, “We didn’t vote in Congress; we didn’t vote to go to war. I signed up to protect this country, I do not choose the wars.”

I submit that this movie is apolitical. Chris Kyle surely was pro-war, but this movie takes a middle ground. How the movie shrewdly pulls this off is by assigning doubts about the war to other characters in the movie. One of his fellow soldiers asks Kyle if he ever reads that Bible he carries around. Another writes a derisive poem about ‘Glory’ that is subsequently read at his own funeral. (Kyle suggests that the attitude that brought about the poem got the soldier killed but the movie itself gives the poem reverential treatment.) Kyle’s brother upon leaving Iraq after a tour tells him, “Fuck this place” as if coming there was the worst decision he ever made in his life. The multitude of viewpoints amongst the veterans in the movie is what makes this movie pro-veteran first than about any sort of politics. If there was a veteran that felt it, this movie wants to show it. Movies about controversial topics generally make their characters choose sides and then take a side as well, which usually has the effect of judging those characters that picked the wrong side. I think it is fair to say that “American Sniper” supports everyone. Clint Eastwood directed this movie. It is arguably his best movie since “Unforgiven” in 1993. It is very inspiring to see a movie with this much energy and precision made by a guy in his mid-80s. Eastwood has made good movies in the last decade (Million Dollar Baby, Gran Torino) but they generally felt like an old man who wasn’t about to make a great movie ever again made them. I was wrong.

I was also wrong about what I felt was the natural range of Bradley Coopers’ acting ability. This is arguably his best performance and a role he almost completely disappears into. If you had asked me to cast someone like Chris Kyle, Bradley Cooper would not have been my first choice. But here he gains a good amount of weight in pure muscle, grows a beard, and has a great sounding Texan accent. He pulls off two counterintuitive personality traits: Being a macho guy but not being conceited about it. That is to say he completely loses the Romantic Comedy pretty boy without completely gaining the Schwarzeneggarian action hero. The story, the performance, the very strong writing, and the clarity of the directing, elevate Chris Kyle’s life into the realm of Shakespearean tragedy. That is to say the character traits of Chris Kyle, namely his comfort with firearms and his unwavering convictions, make him great on the battlefield and at the same time provide for his downfall post-war. The last two scenes of this movie involve him jokingly pointing a revolver at his wife (perhaps the biggest do not do in the annals of gun safety) and then taking a veteran with PTSD to a shooting range because gee isn’t shooting things a fun thing to do. What is the rule for biopics: If it were completely fictional would it be any good. This movie would be great even if there were no real Chris Kyle.

There are two minor problems with the movie that I felt could have been done better. One was the treatment of Chris Kyle’s Iraqi doppelganger, an Olympic sharpshooter that plays for the other side and becomes Kyle’s main antagonist throughout the movie. I don’t believe he gets any lines and his life on the other side is unexplored. It would have been cool if we learned more about him. Also the movie’s pinnacle action sequence suffers from we may call a “Fury” problem if anyone remembers my review of that movie from last fall. The Iraqi insurgents display a stunning lack of tactics when they attack a building holding only four Americans and suffer countless casualties. That sort of thing never happens in a war and is a letdown in a movie that otherwise took the war scenes seriously. But it wasn’t that bad and didn’t wholly compromise the seriousness of the movie.

Go see “American Sniper." Bring along a sense of empathy.



Tuesday, February 17, 2015

A Most Violent Year (4/5 Stars)





“I have always taken the most right path”
- Abel Morales

The fate of this movie may be a prime example of the whims of zeitgeist. Just like it sometimes feels a mega hit comes out of nowhere (see “American Sniper”), so can a strong well made movie go nowhere for no particular reason. Writer/Director J.C. Chandor’s third feature “A Most Violent Year” did not make much money or garner a high number of award nominations (strikingly The National Board of Review made it their movie of the year though it should be noted that this designation happened before everyone else, including the Oscars, completely ignored the film). Perhaps though this movie should not yet be written to the dust heap. I have a feeling that the maker is so strong that we might be discovering this ‘lost’ movie ten-twenty years from now. It is further proof that Chandor is as versatile as he is competent. His first movie was ‘Margin Call’ an intricately detailed and highly expository view of high finance on the day of a stock market meltdown. His second movie was the exact opposite. He ditched all the words and wrote a nearly silent movie about one old man at sea named “All is Lost.” This time he switches direction again with a period piece about a heating oil business under attack by rising crime in 1981. It looks and feels entirely different from his first two movies except for the invisible sure hand of the director behind it. Sometimes when you see a movie you can just sense the controlled confidence of a Director with a capital ‘D.’ Alfred Hitchcock movies have this feeling. So do Stanley Kubrick and Christopher Nolan movies. The movies of young J.C. Chandor have this feeling as well.

The story concerns an immigrant Abel Morales (Oscar Isaac) and his wife Anna Morales (Jessica Chastain). Abel is on the verge of expanding his business greatly by buying a refinery for his heating oil business. He has just given a down payment of $40,000 and expects to close the deal with bank financing at the end of the month. At the same time somebody has been hijacking his trucks and selling his oil at a discounted rate to one of his competitors. At the same time the district attorney (David Oyelowo) has started an investigation into his company for complying with the standard industry practices which were generally fraudulent. His wife, who has mob connections, does the books for his company. His lawyer is played by Albert Brooks who has completed the transformation from a young neurotic comedian to an old steely dramatic actor. The man is a heavy now and fits in great with the last great character of this movie, the brooding emptied out noir scape of 1980s New York City. I did not live in NYC during this time but I’ve seen the movies that were made in the early 1980s. One in particular, Escape From New York, imagined a future where the island of Manhattan was transformed into a high security prison populated entirely by criminals. People were not very optimistic back then and you can feel it in this movie.

There is violence in “A Most Violent Year,” but it is portrayed in a way that is almost never seen in movies. Whereas an action movie generally has highly stylized set pieces that ignore many real world implications this movie dives right into the nitty gritty of real life. Take these plot points. There is a discussion as to whether the drivers in the heating oil trucks should be carrying firearms. This is a concern because if a driver shoots a gun on a crowded highway, whether in self-defense or not, it has huge legal ramifications for the company. And if the legal inquiries happen that may scare off the financing from the bank that is central to the real estate deal. I wish action movies would take a look at how J.C. Chandor has made this movie because the violence that takes place albeit with fewer explosions has far more weight and suspense ingrained in it. There is even a car chase in this movie, which simply does not feel like a regular car chase scene. It feels dangerous. For example, if they were to plow into a street cart of fruit (which does not happen but does happen in every other movie with a car chase) you can bet that the owner of said fruitcart would have a major part in the movie. 

The look of the movie is where J.C. Chandor is being his most innovative in this movie. “A Most Violent Year” follows the great cinematic tradition of period pieces that present the world of the past through the film stock of those years. If you are ever wondering why so many movies that take place pre 1960s are black and white or have at least some of the color drained out of them, well we remember those decades that way because all the movies were black and white. This is the same with the graininess of the 1970s. And here, the advent of videotape with its over saturated reds and browns gives “A Most Violent Year” its warm 1980s look. Certainly walking down the street in 1981 did not look like we see it in this movie but we remember it that way because that’s how we recorded it back then. Oh and my favorite set piece is the NYC subway completely overwritten with angry graffiti. That more than anything represents what is known as the Bad Old Days.

The acting is great. Jessica Chastain as always fits in perfectly with whatever she is doing. Oscar Isaac has the keen ability to look like someone who no longer walks around the modern world. In fact, in one of his first major roles he played a Roman Centurion (“Agora”). That sounds about right. I want to see him in a movie where he plays the antagonist in some ancient battle against Russell Crowe. It think he will do a very good job in his next movie that takes place a long long time ago in a galaxy far far away.

Oh and I was a fan of the Jews, those Orthodox Jews that inhabit South Williamsburg. Those are the guys that Abel does the real estate deal with. I used to do real estate deals with those guys too. You can just tell that anything that happens in NYC from the best to the worst, those guys are going to be relatively unaffected by it. They have their own culture and they have it for the long haul. 


Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Selma (2/5 Stars)




It’s been awhile since I’ve seen an incompentent movie in a theater. I don’t like seeing incompetent movies. They make me mad. So I do my homework. One tool I have is RottenTomatoes.com, a website that aggregates the film reviews. “Selma” had a 99% rating on RottenTomatoes before I went and saw it. Another tool is the endless slew of awards handed out at the end of each year. “Selma” garnered an Oscar nomination for Best Picture and another for Best Song. That is an odd pairing of nominations. Best Song is generally a bullshit award (because of the lack of movies that have original songs) and Best Picture should in theory be the hardest nomination to get (because every movie is up for it). The newspapers (I read NY Times) went to work in decrying a racially based snub for this movie’s director (Ava Duvernay) and starring actor (David Oyelowo) among others. The evidence: Selma was directed by a black woman and was about a black civil rights leader. What was striking about the dialogue going on in the NYTimes is that emphasis was put on the fact that there are no black actors nominated in any of the top categories this year from “Selma” or any other movie. This allegedly is proof that the Academy has a diversity problem. What did not receive much emphasis is whether the movies or performances were any good. And in not paying any attention to that, people got hurt. And by people, I mean me. I spent an uncomfortable two hours watching this movie when I otherwise wouldn’t have if there had been more of a discussion of the movie’s merits. There is a difference between what I found wrong with “The Imitation Game,” a biopic I felt was competently made but focused on the wrong aspects of the story and “Selma,” which is not competently made period. Is this an affirmative action honoree for Best Picture? Well, not exactly I think, but I will talk about that last. In the meantime here is a list of some things that are wrong with this picture.

Let’s start at the beginning:

Two scenes start this movie that have little to do with Selma, Alabama. One is Martin Luther King, Jr. accepting a Nobel Prize in Sweden. The second is a bombing of a church that kills four little girls. Now, these are important moments in Civil Rights History but the movie shows a confusion of scope by using them to introduce this particular story. What is this movie about? Is it a biopic of MLK in which the Nobel Prize scene would make sense. Is it about the Civil Rights Struggle in general in which a church bombing that does not take place in Selma and does not involve MLK would make sense. Or is it about MLK’s actions in Selma to call attention to vote discrimination and the passage of the 1965 Voting Rights Act (I argue that it is) in which neither of the above scenes would be a relevant introduction. There is a scene about five-ten minutes into this movie in which an old woman (played by Oprah Winfrey, a producer as well) is denied the right to register to vote. Ditch the first two scenes,  open with that, and then stick to Selma (or make an entirely different movie). I will give two examples of great movies that are about the same subject. One is “Ghandi” which is a biographical epic that does a very good job of telling a large story with many people over the lifetime of its main character. The second is “Bloody Sunday” which concerns itself with one day of a civil rights struggle in Northern Ireland. A story with MLK could have gone either way. This movie tried to do both and weighed down by the mass of material it cut corners to the point that neither type of story worked.

The antagonists do not make any sense. Now we all know that Southern white people in the 1960s hate black people. I’m not debating that reality. But for a movie to work, the bad guys need to be explained. Remember the rule of biopics: Would this movie be any good if it were completely fictional? And I suspect it would be utterly confusing and impossible to follow if one did not already know what was going to happen (I did). The reasons why white people hate black people do not have to be persuasive but they do need to be understandable. Leonardo Dicaprio’s phrenology presentation in “Django Unchained” is especially prescient. “In the Heat of the Night” and “Burning Mississippi” both do great jobs of explaining the white characters in it. Or if you really want to understand racism, I mean really understand it from the inside out, watch “Birth of a Nation.” It is all right there. The takeaway from “Selma” is that white people don’t like black people just because they don't. This black/white treatment renders a scene 3/4ths of the way into the movie inexplicable: the appearance of plenty of white people who want to take part in the civil rights march. Who are these white people? Where do they come from? What makes them different from every other white person in the story?

The writer Paul Webb and the Director Ava Duvernay do not do the black characters that much justice either. Like most poorly written movies, there are at the same time too many characters and not enough of them. That is to say that the amount of people milling about without proper introductions or job descriptions make for a confusing mess and at the same time only MLK Jr. is given enough screen time to render an impact. Halfway through the movie Cuba Gooding Jr. starts talking with Martin Sheen about something. I had no idea who they were or how they were involved in the story. In a later scene we see them in a courtroom. Cuba is a lawyer. Martin is a judge. ANYWAY, generally speaking when a movie introduces a character halfway through a movie, they do it by having them meet a character we already know. This gives the two of them the opportunity to shake hands or something and exchange names or whatever. That does not happen in “Selma.” Instead two unknown characters just start talking to each other.

There are also a disconcerting amount of scenes wherein supposedly smart people explain basic things to other supposedly smart people who for some weird reason don't know these basic things. There is one scene where a character (whose name I did not remember) is debating with another person (who I had never seen before) the choice between violent and nonviolent protest. What is astounding is when this takes place: right after the police turned violent on the bridge. The movie makes it seem like the second guy never considered that the police would get ugly and is only thinking of fighting back with violence now. How the hell does a violent police response surprise a grown black man in the South? And would not a scene concerning a discussion of nonviolence vs. violence make more sense before an organized march begins. After all, the whole point of the march is to provoke the police into being violent against non-violent protestors and get the national media to take pictures and report the oppression to the rest of the country thereby turning around popular opinion and pressuring politicians to pass Civil Rights legislation. That is the plan. It is a very good one and MLK Jr. is nothing if not an articulate man. Why did this protestor not know the plan?

Pundits in the NYTimes have made a big deal over how President Lyndon Johnson is portrayed in this movie. Basically he tells MLK Jr. to slow down on Voting Rights so he can implement his War on Poverty. Historians don’t like this because Lyndon Johnson did no such thing. However what is more troubling (as a movie critic) is why it seems the writer made the decision to turn Johnson from a real life ally and into a fictional villain. It seems the writer did it to save himself a big pile of work explaining to the audience how it is that a bill becomes a law. In this movie, the Voting Rights Act becomes a reality once Lyndon Johnson stops stalling and gives a speech to Congress asking them to enact it. It seriously does not get more complex than that. It is a stunning example of political ignorance to suggest that a presidential speech is all that is needed to pass a landmark law. To explain it properly would have not been easy but I submit it was possible and a well-written movie could have done it. Instead we have a movie that may just make people stupider by watching it. 

There are basic problems with editing in some scenes. In one, a conversation between MLK and Johnson is ended with the phrase, “I want you to do something for me.” A scene follows this with Johnson’s aide and an associate of MLK’s. I am now expecting the aide to tell the associate what Johnson wants. Actually the conversation is about something else entirely, a supposed assassination plot. The movie then goes back to MLK and Johnson so Johnson can explain to MLK what he wants. This is called a fake-out and if there is not a good reason for it (I did not see one) it bespeaks incompetence. Another fake-out occured when the editor decided to jump back and forth from a nighttime scene to a daytime scene without immediately explaining that the daytime scene takes place the next day. These are the sorts of things that employ the people at Rifftracks. Now take the big scene, the confrontation on the bridge in Selma. It is an utter mess logistically speaking. Given how fast the horses move and how far we can plainly see them down the bridge in certain wide shots, it makes no sense at all how the movie shows the episode unfolding. It seems that the movie is taking moments from the beginning, middle, and end of the confrontation and mixing them altogether hoping on slow motion action shots to obfuscate the lack of continuity. Even weirder, the scene is narrated IN THE PAST TENSE by an UNINTRODUCED reporter who is not present AT THE SCENE. We later learn that he is narrating into a phone booth after the fact. Who the hell is he? Where was he during the bridge scene? How the fuck does he know what he knows if he wasn’t there? I am getting angry!

Okay I could say more but that is enough for one review. Let’s go back to the previous question: Is this an affirmative action Oscar nomination? Well, not necessarily. The Academy has long had a lack of imagination concerning what kinds of pictures deserve nominations. Notoriously, comedies and blockbusters are always disregarded, whereas inspirational biopics are generally over represented. This year there are four in the Best Picture Race (American Sniper, Selma, Imitation Game, The Theory of Everything). I have only seen two of these (Selma and Imitation Game) but neither deserves to be in the running. It just so happens that it is easier to judge the accuracy of something that has happened (for instance David Oyelowo sounds like MLK Jr.) and it feels right to honor a movie about honorable people (MLK and Alan Turing.) So Affirmative Action, that is certainly not the whole story here. The genre itself is generally subsidized. Who knows, maybe it was Chris Rock that got snubbed. I have not seen “Top Five” but I heard it was very good.

What bothers me most about the storyline of these Oscars is the idea that having all Caucasions automatically makes the choices conservative. The three front-runners are movies by Wes Anderson (The Grand Budapest Hotel), Richard Linklater (Boyhood), and Alejandero Inarritu (Birdman). These movies are nothing like each other, are especially innovative, and the makers have never won Oscars before. Anderson and Linklater in particular have been around for decades refining their very unique style of movies into truly impressive art that can no longer be ignored. Ava Duvernay on the other hand hasn’t done shit. To say she was snubbed disrespects those that were nominated.


Tuesday, January 27, 2015

The Imitation Game (3/5 Stars)




‘The Imitation Game’ suffers from ‘Mighty Ducks’ syndrome, a disease of storytelling born of its namesake. “The Might Ducks” is a Disney movie starring Emilio Esteves. It was a popular movie that made a lot of money and spawned several sequels, not to mention many ripoffs that seemed to change nothing but the sport i.e. The Little Giants, The Big Green. Ostensibly ‘The Mighty Ducks' is about ice hockey, but curiously the more plausible it seems (and thus more enjoyable) is inversely related to the viewer’s knowledge of ice hockey. That is to say the syndrome refers to a movie that is more effective the less the audience is familiar with its subject matter. Perhaps not coincidentally when the NHL expanded to include a team called the Mighty Ducks their home was Anaheim, California, a place that has never had and never will have ice.

“The Imitation Game,” is a biopic of Alan Turing, the British code-breaker responsible for cracking the Nazi Enigma code during World War II. I am not a code-breaking expert. However I can tell when a movie is deliberately not engaging with its subject matter because it either is not smart enough to explain it or does not believe I am smart enough to understand an explanation. If I were a code-breaking expert, and wanted to see this movie about a famous code-breaker, I would expect to be appalled by the sheer lack of attention paid to the science of breaking codes. It must have taken quite a bit of smarts and hard work to crack Enigma. The movie at least explains why it would be so hard. It is a code that has 150 million million combinations and resets every single day. Alan Turing’s great idea was to create a machine fast enough to go through the combinations in a single day. I have not the slightest clue how Turing came up with that idea or how the machine worked. Here is what the movie was concerned with instead: Turing was not very good at making friends and the people he worked with did not like his dismissive and arrogant attitude. Therefore, according to the movie, in order to break the code and win the war Turing has to draw up enough social grace to give apples to his colleagues and tell a joke about a bear in the woods. That (and not his genius) is what won over the room so they could finally work out his idea.

Anyone with some concept of how dangerous the World War going on outside will understand how petty this movie’s insistence on the importance of social drama was to the greater scheme of things. And anyone with some concept of how code-breaking machines work will be eternally frustrated with how the movie completely sidesteps any discussion of code-breaking theory. And anyone who has some respect for the intelligence of past generations will roll their eyes at the way the screenwriter has chosen to dumb down the characters in order to help what they must have assumed to be a pitifully ill informed modern audience. A good example is when the codebreakers are first presented with a stolen Enigma machine. One of the men asks why they don’t just type an intercepted radio code into it. The makers of the movie (Director Morten Tyldum, screenwriter Graham More) are under the impression that the audience does not know that Enigma is more complicated than that, so not unlike a sacrificial lamb given unto slaughter to sate the gods of idiots a real historical figure has been made to pretend he is not smart enough to know not to ask stupid questions. A little later in the same scene the head of MI:6, the British secret service, is introduced. Another poor bastard asks, “But the military only has five divisions.” No shit. The Secret Service is secret. Why would a person hired to break a top secret Nazi code be adamant about the impossibility of a secret intelligence division in the army when he is literally already apart of it? Quack, Quack, Quack!

This stupid pandering to modern sensibilities reaches the level of questionable storytelling ethics when it concerns the homosexuality of its subject Alan Turing. We all know now that there is nothing wrong with homosexuality, the key word being ‘now.’ They did not know that then. Alan Turing probably did not even know that then. The way to honor the experience of real people is to show what it was like through their eyes. But here whenever a character learns of Turing’s homosexuality they not only know what it is literally, but also act as if they do not believe it is a moral choice of Turing’s. Furthermore are sympathetic to him even the policeman who, more than anybody else, has no historical reason to be. These are reactions that supposedly take place side by side in a time period where Turing would later be chemically castrated by the government for his homosexuality and eventually commit suicide. If you want to see how a movie should treat something like this, I recommend “Far From Heaven.” Or not pay attention to it at all. If you asked Alan Turing what he felt was most interesting about his character, do you suspect he would mention his homosexuality or the giant precomputer he spent day and night developing for years. How about we focus on that a little?

There is a reason to see this movie though and that is the always-superb performance by Benedict Cumberbatch as Alan Turing. The man has made a career out of playing geniuses such as Sherlock Holmes and Frankenstein and here he does another version of a very smart man. His Turing is a far less smooth and confident as his Sherlock, but the underlying intelligence is immediately apparent. Turing apparently had a stammer and Cumberbatch performs it well. So that’s good. But hold fast, and I wonder if anyone else picked up on this. Take the character that Keira Knightley plays. She gets a job as a codebreaker by filling out an extremely hard crossword in the London paper and finishing an unfinishable test before a classroom of other applicants. So she too is super duper smart. Amazingly though, she is not beset with the quirks and characteristics of a genius that Cumberbatch brings to his role. She spends a great more time on screen being a love interest/plucky feminist than being a nerd that's very good at math. What’s going on there you may ask? Or not ask. I don’t think anybody but me has.

What stops these performances from being awards worthy has more to do with the mediocre movie that they are attached to. This one has been getting awards buzz lately. I don’t agree with that. And I also think it was a rip-off of “A Beautiful Mind,” to have the breakthrough in the code-breaking take place in a bar in a scene concerned with the unspoken code of human mating habits. For fuck's sake Hollywood not everything is about sex.

 I think Mark Zuckerberg said it best when he was asked about, “The Social Network.”

“The whole framing of the movie is I’m with this girl who doesn’t exist in real life who then dumps me…and basically the whole reason for making Facebook is because I wanted to get girls or get into some social institution…It’s such a big disconnect from the way people who make movies think of what we do in Silicon Valley, building stuff. They just can’t wrap their head around the idea that someone might build something because they like building things.” (cue wild applause from audience of engineers)

Exactly.


Monday, January 19, 2015

Inherent Vice (5/5 Stars)




I have waited too long to review this movie. As I sit down to write I am reviewing in my mind what happened where when and how and this is a huge mistake because I hardly had a grasp on that when I was watching the movie in the theater. But dig this: during the movie I did not care because like the best of Chandler-esque pot detectives (see The Long Goodbye and The Big Lebowski) this movie makes its money moment to moment not in the grand scheme of things and boy is this movie filled from top to bottom with moments. It’s stacked with jokes like the flattop of Flintstone proportions that neatly sits on Lietuenant Detective (and SAG member) Christian F. “BigFoot” Bjornsen’s fat head.

Inherent Vice was adapted from a Thomas Pynchon novel and directed by Paul Thomas Anderson. It is like a bonus movie from this guy in that his last two movies each took five years to make and market. Not only is this one coming to us within two years of his last (‘The Master’) but it is also a comedy and certainly the funniest P.T. Anderson movie to date. There has been an extraordinary amount of effort made here to include at least one visual gag in every scene. Some are very good like say the “welcome” “Doc” gets to the LA police department, Bigfoot’s son pouring him a drink, and the parking technique of his assistant. Roger Ebert once said of Steven Soderbergh’s ‘Ocean 11’ that it felt like a virtuoso classical pianist went down to the local honkytonk and started riffing on some ragtime melodies for fun. That’s what this feels like too. P.T. Anderson is slumming it with the low culture comedians. That’s probably why this movie will not be recognized for anything even though it should be on par with all his other high class movies.

Now for your reading enjoyment I will attempt to summarize the plot. May the gods of Imdb guide me! This movie is about Larry “Doc” Sportello a hippie private detective in the early 1970s of Los Angeles. I am assuming he got the nickname ‘Doc’ because he works out of a doctor’s office. One night Doc’s ex-girlfriend Shasta Fay Hepworth (Katherine Waterston) shows up needing his help. Her boyfriend, the married real estate devloper Mickey Wolfman, may be the target of a kidnapping plot by his wife and her boyfriend. Doc can’t turn this request down as that girl has a hold of him the way that certain women often do. Thus the convoluted journey begins where a murder at a whorehouse brings him in contact with Lt. Det. Christian F. “Bigfoot” Bjornsen (a perfect Josh Brolin), which necessitates the appearance of Doc’s maritime lawyer Sauncho Smilax, Esq. (Benicio Del Toro) and his current girlfriend Deputy D.A. Penny Kimball (Reese Witherspoon). The FBI gets in on the case and something called the Golden Fang, which might be a boat or something bigger leads the increasingly convoluted storyline through other bright character spots such as Dr. Rudy Blatnoyd D.D.S (a manic Martin Short) and Coy Harlingen (Owen Wilson). The conversation that Doc has with Coy is perhaps the low point of clarity in the movie since it takes place after at least an hour of hard to follow and might consist of codespeak. I don’t know I’m not sure because I probably would not know what they were talking about even if it wasn’t in code.

The confusing aspect of Inherent Vice is medicated quite a bit like the confusing way of The Big Lebowski is medicated: that is with lots of drugs and enough great stuff going on in the moment that the viewer does not necessarily need to have a big picture in order to enjoy himself. Perhaps the best self-contained ten minutes of the movie is the introduction and dispensation of Martin Short, a dentist who may or may not be one small cog in a vast conspiracy to get hippies on heroin and then sell them everything they need to get off of heroin (heroin apparently does awful things to your teeth). ANYWAY it is a manic creation of unbridled lust and hard drugs before we are informed in the subsequent scene that the dentist has broken in his neck in a trampoline accident. Of course it may not be an accident but we’ve already moved on.

I haven’t read the book but I get the feeling that it is an irretrievably unadaptable source and the fact that P.T. Anderson has made a good movie from it makes the adaptation itself extraordinary. He should at least get an Oscar nomination for the screenplay. The movie is filled to the brim with memorable characters but Josh Brolin’s performance is one flattop head above the rest. He too should get an Oscar nomination. Joaquin Phoenix does a wonderful job of holding his own among the nutcases. Oh and I forgot that the movie is narrated by a character that is kind of tangential to the whole thing. Someone explained to me that she knows everything via stoner ESP or whatever. It works just as well.

I liked this movie quite a bit and will probably have to see it again to get most of the jokes. I hope you see it at least once and don’t feel bad if you can’t entirely figure what is going on. I suspect nobody can, especially the hippies.